History of state-formation processes in america, Humanities

Assignment Help:

Pieter Spierenburg (2006) has advanced the provocative thesis that, in the history of state-formation processes in America, ‘democracy came too early'. In most parts of Western Europe, there took place over many centuries gradual processes of centralisation, eventuating in the concentration of the means of violence in fewer and fewer hands, and ultimately in the establishment of a relatively effective monopoly apparatus in the hands of kings. Gradual it may have been, but the struggles among a warrior elite were bloody, as more and more players were deprived of their capacity to wage war independently of the central ruler. The process was in its ?nal stages when European colonisation of North America began. Once stable and effective royal monopolies of violence had been established, as they were in general by the late seventeenth and the eighteenth centuries, the people's aim in subsequent struggles - most spectacularly in the French Revolution - was not to challenge or destroy the monopoly as such, but rather to ‘co-possess' the monopoly. In other words, the aim was to assert a more broadly based control over those who exercised the monopoly, to democratise it.

In North America, however, 'there was no phase of centralisation before democratisation set in', and 'democracy came to America too early'. By that he means something quite factual:

'the inhabitants had lacked the time to become accustomed to being disarmed. As a consequence, the idea remained alive that the very existence of a monopoly of force was undesirable. And it remained alive in an increasingly democratic  form: not  [as  in medieval Europe] of  regional  elites  carving out  their private principality, but of common people claiming the right of self-defence. (...) Local elites and, increasingly, common people equated democracy with the right of armed protection of  their own property and  interests'  (Spierenburg 2006: 109-10).

Spierenburg acknowledges that it would be an oversimpli?cation to suggest that the transition from struggles to destroy the monopoly apparatus to struggles to co-possess it did not take place at all in the usa, but 'the best one can say is that the majority of the population wanted it both ways': they 'accepted the reality of government institutions but at the same time they cherished an ethic of self-help'.  'Today', remarks Spierenburg,  'the idea that individuals cannot and should not rely on state institutions in order to protect their homes is alive and well. Members of the Michigan Militia explicitly say so in [Michael Moore's 2003 documentary ?lm] Bowling for Columbine' (2006: 110).


Related Discussions:- History of state-formation processes in america

Modes of mass media, Modes of Mass Media Some of the significant repre...

Modes of Mass Media Some of the significant representatives of mass media are: • Print media - initially newspapers and popular magazines; • Radio broadcasting; • Tele

An overview of the formation of amnesty international, Question 1 Discuss ...

Question 1 Discuss the significance of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights Question 2 Critically assess the provisions relating to the implementation of International

Differentiate moral and ethics, Differentiate Moral and Ethics?  MORAL...

Differentiate Moral and Ethics?  MORAL:  Refers only to personal behavior. Refers to any aspect of human action Social conventions about right or wrong condu

Political philosophy, I need report on Political Philosophy . Do you provi...

I need report on Political Philosophy . Do you provide help in topic Political Philosophy ? I need expert's assistance to solve my college assignment. Please suggest if it work

Role of a thesaurus in indexing and searching, Role of a Thesaurus in Index...

Role of a Thesaurus in Indexing and Searching   The thesaurus contributes to consistency in  indexing between indexers and reduces incorrect term assignments to a great extent

Neo-taoist escapism, Yellow Turban Revolt 184-189. Inspired by Daoists, ad...

Yellow Turban Revolt 184-189. Inspired by Daoists, adversary was Confucianism. Incredibly devastating. Provinces were ravaged: could put nothing to use. Han Confucian officials we

Location theory, Location Theory: This theory, in geography and economics, ...

Location Theory: This theory, in geography and economics, theory regarded along with the geographic location of economic activity; this has turn into an integral part of regional s

Foundation course in science and technology, discuss briefly the scientific...

discuss briefly the scientific and technical achievements of bronze age

What is the use of risk -analysis, What is the use of Risk -Analysis? What ...

What is the use of Risk -Analysis? What are the three factors involved here?  Risk Analysis is used for the assessment of the hazardous associated with an industrial or commerc

Subject bibliography, Subject The subject bibliographies form the larg...

Subject The subject bibliographies form the largest group of enumerative bibliographies. It is defined as the one that deals with the materials pertaining to a single given su

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd