General limitations of net present value, Financial Accounting

Assignment Help:

General limitations of Net Present Value when applied to investment appraisal

NPV is a generally used technique employed in investment appraisal but is subject to a number of restrictive assumptions as well as limitations which call into question its general relevance. However if the assumptions and limitations are understood then its application is less likely to be undertaken in error.

A few of the difficulties with NPV are listed below

- NPV presumes that firms pursue an objective of maximising the wealth of their shareholders. This is doubtful given the wider range of stakeholders who might have conflicting interests to those of the shareholders.

- NPV is mainly redundant if organisations are not wealth maximising. For instance public sector organisations may wish to invest in capital assets but will use non profit objectives as part of their assessment.

- NPV is potentially a hard method to apply in the context of having to estimate what is the correct discount rate to use. This is particularly therefore when questions arise as to the incorporation of risk premier in the discount rate since an evaluation of the risk of the business or of the project in particular will have to be made and which may be difficult to discern. Other approaches to risk analysis such as sensitivity and decision trees are subject to fairly severe limitations.

- NPV suppose that cash surpluses can be reinvested at the discount rate. This is subject to other projects mortal available which produce at least a zero NPV at the chosen discount rate.

- NPV is able to most easily cope with cash flows arising at period ends and isn't a technique that is used easily when complicated mid-period cash flows are present.

- NPV isn't universally employed especially in a small business environment. The available evidence proposes that businesses assess projects in a variety of ways (IRR, payback, accounting rate of return). The reality that such methods are used which are theoretically inferior to NPV calls into question the practical benefits of NPV and therefore hints at certain practical limitations.

- The conclusion from NPV examination is the present value of the surplus cash generated from a project. If reported profits are significant to businesses then it is possible that there may be a conflict between undertaking a positive NPV project and potentially adverse consequences on reported profits. This will mainly be the case for projects with long horizons large initial investment and very delayed cash inflows. In such conditions businesses may prefer to use accounting measures of investment appraisal.

- Managerial incentive schemes mayn't be consistent with NPV particularly when long time horizons are involved. Thus managers possibly rewarded on the basis of accounting profits in the short term and may be encouraged to act in accordance with these objectives and thus ignore positive NPV projects. This may be a difficulty of the incentive schemes and not of NPV however a potential conflict exists and represents a difficulty for NPV.

- NPV treats all time periods evenly with the exception of discounting far cash flows more than near cash flows. In other sense NPV only accounts for the time value of money. To several businesses distant horizons are less important than near horizons if only because that is the environment in which they work. Other factors moreover applying higher discount rates may work to reduce the impact of distant years. For instance in the long term nearly all aspects of the business may change and hence a too-narrow focus on discounting means that NPV is of limited value and more so the further the time horizon considered.

- NPV is of restricted use in the face of non-quantifiable benefits or costs. NPV doesn't take account of non-financial information which may even be relevant to shareholders who want their wealth maximised. For instance issues of strategic benefit may happen against which it is difficult to immediately quantify the benefits but for which there are immediate costs. NPV would treat such a circumstances as an additional cost since it could not incorporate the indiscernible benefit.


Related Discussions:- General limitations of net present value

Adjustments, Is goodwill a fictitious asset?

Is goodwill a fictitious asset?

Determine the yield to maturity of the bond, The current market price of a ...

The current market price of a Leigh bond is $1,297.6. If the coupon rate is 10% and the par value is equal to $1,000, what is the yield to maturity of the bond if it matures in 10

Prepare a statement of financial position, SE CTION A QUESTION 1: ...

SE CTION A QUESTION 1: Below is a trial balance of a manufacturer of boots for the local market. Trial balance as at 31st December 2012 Dr Rs

Hsa advantages , A HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNT AT FRONTLINE PR Susan Berry...

A HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNT AT FRONTLINE PR Susan Berry just returned from a national conference on compensation and benefits where she attended a session on Health Savings Accou

Accounting for incomplete records , Mr. Surya does not keep a systematic re...

Mr. Surya does not keep a systematic record of his transactions. He is able to give you the following information regarding his assets and liabilities. 2000 2001 Dec. 31 Dec. 3

Investment, compute the arithmetic mean rate of return and standard deviati...

compute the arithmetic mean rate of return and standard deviation of rates of return for the two series

Use the multi factor productivity ratio, Alyssa's Custom Cakes currently se...

Alyssa's Custom Cakes currently sells 5 birthday, 2 wedding, and 3 specialty cakes each month for $50, $150, and $100 each, respectively.. The cost of labor is $50 per hour includi

the current stock price of great pumpkins farms, Great Pumpkin Farms just ...

Great Pumpkin Farms just paid a dividend of $3.50 on its stock.  The growth rate in dividends is expected to be a constant 5 percent per year indefinitely.  Investors need a 16 per

Show the management report, Q. Show the Management Report? Management's...

Q. Show the Management Report? Management's Report - Management is essential to include in its annual report its assessment of the effectiveness of the company's internal contr

Specific accounting and related issues , Joe seeks your assistance in asses...

Joe seeks your assistance in assessing these investment options. He has five particular concerns, as outlined below. 1. Regarding his photographic studio, which would be a bette

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd