Explain what the law is in this situation, Corporate Finance

Assignment Help:

Corporation Hallmark, located in California, was in the business of manufacturing custom-ordered greeting cards, boxes, wrapping paper, and other paper products. Its operation is vertically integrated and includes the production of paper products from raw materials and wastepaper as well as its composition into the finished products ordered by customers.  During this time, Hallmark controlled 35 foreign subsidiaries located in Asia, Australia and Africa.  Its percentage ownership of the subsidiaries (ether directly or though other subsidiaries) ranged between 50% to 100%.  In those instances, where Hallmark did not own a 100% interest in the subsidiaries, the remainder was owned by local nationals.  Five of the subsidiaries were holding companies that had no payroll, sales or property, but did have income. Another three were inactive.  The rest were all engaged in their respective local markets in essentially the same business as Hallmark.

Most of Hallmark's subsidiaries were, like Hallmark itself, fully integrated, although a few bought paper products from elsewhere.  Sales of materials from Hallmark to its subsidiaries accounted for about 40% of the subsidiaries total purchases.  The subsidiaries were also relatively autonomous with respect to matters of personnel and day-to-day management.  For example transfer of personnel from Hallmark to its subsidiaries were rare and occurred only when a subsidiary could not fill a position locally.  Training was conducted for the subsidiaries' employees in California and in other countries. Hallmark and its subsidiaries visited each other frequently to familiarize themselves with Hallmark's method of operation.  Hallmark charged four senior vice presidents and eight other officers with the task of overseeing the operation of the subsidiaries.  These officers established general standards of professionalism, profitability and ethical process and dealt with major problems and long-term decisions; day-to-day management of the subsidiaries, however, was left in the hands of local executives who were always citizens of the host country.  However, whenever the subsidiaries needed help, they would call/email/text Hallmark.  Although local decisions regarding capital expenditures were subject to review by Hallmark, problems were generally worked out by consensus rather than outright domination. Hallmark also had a number of its directors and officers on the boards of directors of the subsidiaries, but they did not generally play an active role in management decision.

The relationship between Hallmark and the subsidiaries were close.  For example approximately 75% of the subsidiaries' long-term debt was either held directly, or guaranteed by Hallmark.  Hallmark also provides advice and consultation regarding manufacturing techniques, engineering, design, and architecture by entering into technical service agreements or by informal arrangements.  Hallmark did not provide insurance but when needed would provide accounting work to the subsidiaries.  Hallmark many times helped its subsidiaries in their procurement of equipment either by selling them used equipment of its own or by employing its own purchasing department to act as agent for the subsidiaries.

a)   Whether Hallmark and its subsidiaries constituted a unitary business;

b)   If so, whether the apportionment was fair;

c)   If so, did the Foreign Commerce Clause preclude California from applying its combined reporting approach on a worldwide basis?


Related Discussions:- Explain what the law is in this situation

Initial data exploration, Some aggregate figures concerning the available d...

Some aggregate figures concerning the available data are shown in Table 1. The sizes of both the assortment groups and the product groups vary greatly across the groups. In Season

Market efficiency, differentiate between allocative efficiency and price ef...

differentiate between allocative efficiency and price efficiency

DIVIDEND POLICY, The managing directors of three profitable listed companie...

The managing directors of three profitable listed companies discussed their company’s dividend policies at a business lunch. Company A has deliberately paid no dividends for the p

Net present value, Based on its Net Present Value (NPV), should the followi...

Based on its Net Present Value (NPV), should the following project be accepted?  Please assume a discount rate of 10%.

Stocks, The stock price of Jenkins Co. is $53. Investors require a 12 perce...

The stock price of Jenkins Co. is $53. Investors require a 12 percent rate of return on similar stocks. If the company plans to pay a dividend of $3.15 next year, what growth rate

Merger and aquisition, It is given that company A will acquire company B wi...

It is given that company A will acquire company B with shares of common stock. Present earnings of A is rs. 20 million and of company B is rs. 5 million. Earning price per share of

Growthg and assets, a firm wishes to maintain an internal growth rate of 6....

a firm wishes to maintain an internal growth rate of 6.5% and the dividend payout ratio of 25%. The current profit margin is 6%, and the firm uses no external financing sources. Wh

RISK AND RETURN, A person is willing to sell some stock

A person is willing to sell some stock

What is the value of equity of alpha, Two firms, Alpha and Beta, are in the...

Two firms, Alpha and Beta, are in the same business and size and identical in all respects except the way in which they have financed their assets. If the economy does well in th

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd