Dynamically loadable kernel modules, Operating System

Assignment Help:

Q. Dynamically loadable kernel modules give elasticity when drivers are added to a system however do they have disadvantages too? Under what situations would a kernel be compiled into a single binary file and when would it be better to keep it split into modules? Describe your answer.

Answer: There are two principal disadvantages with the use of modules.

The initial one is size- a module management consumes un-page-able kernel memory as well as a basic kernel with a number of modules loaded will consume more memory than an equivalent kernel with the drivers compiled into the kernel image itself. This can be a extremely significant issue on machines with limited physical memory.

The second disadvantage is that modules can increase the complexity of the kernel bootstrap process. It is hard to load-up a set of modules as of disk if the driver needed to access that disk itself a module that needs to be loaded. Consequently managing the kernel bootstrap with modules can require extra work on the part of the administrator the modules necessary to bootstrap require to be placed into a ram disk image that is loaded alongside the early kernel image when the system is initialized.

In certain cases it is better to utilize a modular kernel as well as in other cases it is better to utilize a kernel with its device drivers pre-linked. Where reducing the size of the kernel is important the choice will depend on how frequently the various device drivers are used. If they are in constant utilize then modules are unsuitable. This is particularly true where drivers are needed for the boot process itself. On the other way if some drivers aren't always needed then the module mechanism allows those drivers to be loaded and unloaded on demand potentially offering a net saving in physical memory.

Where a kernel is to be built that should be usable on a large variety of awfully different machines then building it with modules is clearly preferable to using a single kernel with dozens of unnecessary drivers consuming memory. This is principally the case for commercially distributed kernels where supporting the widest diversity of hardware in the simplestmanner possible are a priority.

Nevertheless if a kernel is being built for a single machine whose configuration is known in move forwards then compiling and using modules may merely be an unnecessary complexity. In cases similar to this the use of modules may well be a matter of taste.


Related Discussions:- Dynamically loadable kernel modules

Major advantage of the layered approach to system design, Q. What is the ma...

Q. What is the major advantage of the layered approach to system design? What are the de-merits of using the layered approach? Answer: As in all cases of modular design as well

Describe the possible rmi invocation semantics, Question: (a) Briefly d...

Question: (a) Briefly discuss and describe the possible RMI invocation semantics. (b) (i) What is data marshaling? (ii) Explain the role of a remote object reference dur

Different ways in which a thread can be cancelled, What are the different w...

What are the different ways in which a thread can be cancelled? Cancellation of a target thread may happen in two different scenarios: Asynchronous cancellation: One thr

Explain disk scheduling algorithms-shortest seek time first, SSTF (Shortest...

SSTF (Shortest Seek Time First) After a demand go to the closest request in the work queue regardless of direction Decrease total seek time compared to FCFS Disadv

Explain swapping technique used in pre-3bsd unix systems?, What are the dis...

What are the disadvantages of swapping technique used in pre-3BSD UNIX systems? If there is excessively much memory contention, processes are swapped out until sufficient

Linux, shell script that accepts two directory names as arguments and delet...

shell script that accepts two directory names as arguments and delete those file in the second directory that are identical to the file in the first

Plot a function for value of heights, The performance of a file system depe...

The performance of a file system depends upon the cache hit rate (fraction of blocks found in the cache). If it takes 1 msec to satisfy a request from the cache, but 40 msec to sat

Explain process scheduling in time sharing, Explain process scheduling in t...

Explain process scheduling in time sharing The relevant features of time sharing are: 1.      Process priorities do not depend on the nature of the processes 2.      Proc

Briefly discuss on page replacement, Briefly discuss on page replacement? ...

Briefly discuss on page replacement? Page replacement approach is fixed as follows. If no frame is free, we search one that is not presently being used and free it. We can fre

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd