Arguments against workers participation, HR Management

Assignment Help:

Arguments against workers participation: workers participation is always not favoured by managers because of the following factors:

1. Inefficient workers: some managers discount worker participation on the ground that the workers are inefficient in taking decisions. Decision making in an intellectual job and workers are in general less intelligent when compared to the executives. In the eyes of employers and management workers are less educated incompetent and unintelligent and ineffective in taking decision. Thus it is not necessary for management to allow the workers to participate in decision making.

2. Participation is not possible in complicated issues: it is not always possible to extend participation in some complicated issues like financing marketing managerial functions such as planning organizing coordinating controlling. Today management has become highly professionalized activity demanding experienced experts for solving typical problems encountered by organizations. Decisions taken by professional's management people would be more effective than the decisions taken by the managers at the functional level and employees taken together. It is not rare to hire outside professionals consultants for solving some basic problems encountered by organizations than resorting to simple traditional worker participation.

3. Weak trade unions: in some countries trade unions are weak. US is not an exception to this. In US trade unions are dominated by political pressures and ideologies concentrating least on the welfare of the employees and organizations. Labour is highly unorganized and never works on equal footing posing a problem to participation. Effective worker participation requires strong labour union and welfare motivated ideology rather than weak union and politically motivated ideology.


Related Discussions:- Arguments against workers participation

Strategies adopted in single gender classes, Major "intervention" strategie...

Major "intervention" strategies adopted for single gender classes include, "pedagogical approaches, individual, organizational and socio cultural approaches" (Younger and Warrigton

Response to an organizing drive, After reading through the Zinnia and ACME ...

After reading through the Zinnia and ACME scenarios presented on page 225 of the John Budd text (Labor Relations: Striking a Balance), outline an employer strategic level (organizi

Disadvantages of job enlargement, Disadvantages of job enlargement: 1....

Disadvantages of job enlargement: 1. Job enlargement tends to be a costly affair. Workers may require additional training for their enlarged jobs. Moreover, if the Job enlarge

Work/life employee benefits, Work/Life benefits are "non-traditional" emplo...

Work/Life benefits are "non-traditional" employee benefits that help employees in organizing their lives. Employers buy these services from vendors and they are presented to employ

Distinction between job description and job specification, Distinction betw...

Distinction between job description and job specification: both the documents job description and job specification are the products of the job analysis. But both job description a

Sound reward system, effective human resource management depends upon sound...

effective human resource management depends upon sound reward system comment?

Explain the critical psychological states, Problem 1: Job Characteristi...

Problem 1: Job Characteristic Model: Basic dimensions of jobs and their relationship to psychological states and work outcomes. Using your own job experience: (i) Explain

What are the main components of a reward policy, Question 1: (a) What ...

Question 1: (a) What is a reward policy? (b) What are the main components of a reward policy? Question 2: "The concept of the psychological contract is an important

What can organisations do to manage such conflicts, Question 1: (i) Ex...

Question 1: (i) Explain why it is of utmost importance for organisations to effectively manage their "people". (ii) What are the challenges that organisations are currentl

Explain human relation approach to discipline, Q. Explain Human relation ap...

Q. Explain Human relation approach to discipline? It calls for the training an employee as a human being and considers the totality of his personality and behaviour while corre

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd