Arguments against workers participation, HR Management

Assignment Help:

Arguments against workers participation: workers participation is always not favoured by managers because of the following factors:

1. Inefficient workers: some managers discount worker participation on the ground that the workers are inefficient in taking decisions. Decision making in an intellectual job and workers are in general less intelligent when compared to the executives. In the eyes of employers and management workers are less educated incompetent and unintelligent and ineffective in taking decision. Thus it is not necessary for management to allow the workers to participate in decision making.

2. Participation is not possible in complicated issues: it is not always possible to extend participation in some complicated issues like financing marketing managerial functions such as planning organizing coordinating controlling. Today management has become highly professionalized activity demanding experienced experts for solving typical problems encountered by organizations. Decisions taken by professional's management people would be more effective than the decisions taken by the managers at the functional level and employees taken together. It is not rare to hire outside professionals consultants for solving some basic problems encountered by organizations than resorting to simple traditional worker participation.

3. Weak trade unions: in some countries trade unions are weak. US is not an exception to this. In US trade unions are dominated by political pressures and ideologies concentrating least on the welfare of the employees and organizations. Labour is highly unorganized and never works on equal footing posing a problem to participation. Effective worker participation requires strong labour union and welfare motivated ideology rather than weak union and politically motivated ideology.


Related Discussions:- Arguments against workers participation

What is knowledge management, What is Knowledge Management?  Just as th...

What is Knowledge Management?  Just as there are many definitions of knowledge, there are also numerous definitions of knowledge management. To date, no general approach to man

Explain roi process in the human resource development, Question 1: ‘Dur...

Question 1: ‘During the 1920's, ROI was the emerging tool to place a value on the payoff investment. In recent years, the application of the concept has been expanded to all t

Show ratio trend analysis, Q. Show Ratio trend analysis? Different rati...

Q. Show Ratio trend analysis? Different ratio like total output number of workers, total sales volume or the number of sales persons, direct analysis of the workers / indirect

Working conditions observatory, With all the benefits that groups provide, ...

With all the benefits that groups provide, it is not surprising that Lawler and colleagues (Lawler et al. 1995; Lawler III et al. 1998) found an increased prevalence of this organi

Which method of recruitment used by the organisation, Question : Carefu...

Question : Carefully read the extract of the Le Matinal Newspaper dated 15th September 2010 as annexed and answer the following questions: (i) Which method of recruitment h

What do you mean by personality test, Q. What do you mean by Personality te...

Q. What do you mean by Personality test? Personality test: these tests probe deeply to discover clues to an individual's value system, his emotional relations and maturity and

What type of flexible resourcing method would you choose, Question: Sup...

Question: Suppose you are the Human Resource manager of a well established garment manufacturing enterprise. a) Because of a sudden increase in demand for your product, you

Developments in the theory of motivation, Question 1: a) Outline the ma...

Question 1: a) Outline the major contributions of two of the following authors to the development of management thought: (i) F W Taylor (ii) H Fayol (iii) M Weber b

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd