Would ancient athens still be considered a democratic state

Reference no: EM132197618

GUIDELINES FOR WRITING ASSIGNMENT

The main objective of this assignment is provide students with an opportunity to develop the skill of critical thinking, which, according to the Montclair University General Education Program website,1 includes: "the ability to correctly evaluate their own arguments as well as the conclusions of others.

This skill involves the application of healthy skepticism, determination of factual errors, and the detection of problems and/or inconsistencies in logic and reasoning." In a 1250-word essay, students will analyze the core ideas of an influential ancient Greek
text (in translation), evaluate its significance, forms of reasoning employed in the text, validity of the logic, ideas and concepts presented in the text. Students will form their own opinions and conclusions about the ancient Greek text based on such evaluation.

Instructions: Consider an excerpt from the History of the Peloponnesian War of Thucydides (choose one of the options below). Analyze the main concepts and ideas presented in the text according to the specific guidelines in Options 1 and 2 below. Evaluate the validity of the arguments presented in the text. Support your arguments with concrete examples from the text.

OPTION 1: Pericles' funeral oration: What is democracy?

Reread Pericles' funeral oration in Thucydides 2.35-46, and answer the following question: What specific cultural values, lifestyle choices, and forms of social and political organization and functioning does Pericles consider an integral part of a democracy? In your answer to the question above, be sure to also address the following questions (not necessarily in the same order) and support your answer with the evidence from the text:

(1) If modern criteria of evaluation were applied to Pericles' view of democracy, would ancient Athens still be considered a democratic state?

(2) Are there gaps and/or flaws in Pericles' characterization of democracy?

(3) Do the main principles of democracy outlined by Pericles correspond to the modern (or your own) understanding of equality and justice?

(4) In what specific ways, according to Pericles, is Athenian democracy able to favor both individual rights and the interests of the community?

OPTION 2: The Realpolitik of the Melian dialogue: Justice vs. Expediency.

Reread the Melian Dialogue in Thucydides 5.84-116. Imagine that you are an Athenian who attended a popular assembly in 416 BCE. The Athenian envoys have just reported on the course and results of the negotiations with the Melians. Imagine yourself going to the podium to defend one of the two opposing claims:

either

The Athenians' demand that Melos should become a part of the Athenian Empire is fully justified, it is the right course for the Athenians to force Melos into submission;

The Athenian arguments explaining their right to establish dominance over the Melians are flawed; it is not proper for the Athenians to force Melos into submission.

Be sure to refer to the specific arguments made by both parties, as presented in Thucydides. What are these arguments exactly?

Are they valid or flawed in some way? Do the Athenian demands bear witness to disintegration of morals and democratic values of Athens or are they justified (at least to some degree), considering the circumstances? Remember, there is no right or wrong choice here.

Reference no: EM132197618

Questions Cloud

Identify satisfaction level of the employees : MA508 - Business Statistics - Demonstrate advanced and integrated understanding of situations in which statistical analysis may be useful

Create a plan to deploy technology solutions : Create a plan to deploy technology solutions in alignment with strategic business needs. Manage complex information technology systems.

How did your understanding of the issue change : Youu should provide your own perspective on the issue - how it has been impacted by this project. What did you learn?

What are the corresponding file name : What are common Windows utilities used to maintain Windows? What are the corresponding file name?

Would ancient athens still be considered a democratic state : If modern criteria of evaluation were applied to Pericles' view of democracy, would ancient Athens still be considered a democratic state?

Does the company have appropriate functional strategies : Given Best Buy’s internal and external environment, does the company have appropriate functional strategies?

How you have applied some key concepts from your readings : In a 2-3 page paper, reflect on your work experience during this internship, and provide context to your learning by juxtaposing your experiences.

Five stages of group and team development : How might you have helped the group work through that stage differently based upon what you know now about the five stages of group and team development?

Type of lease is riskiest in terms of operating expenses : You are taking on the role of a commercial property owner/manager. Which type of lease is riskiest in terms of operating expenses?

User Account

All Pages