Would a kantian vote differently than a utilitarian

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133671937

Assignment:

You are a U.S. Senator. You represent your home state. The House of Representatives has sent the Senate a bill that will forgive all college student loan debt in perpetuity. It is up to the Senate to pass it and send it to the president to be signed into law. You are the swing vote. If you vote yes, it will pass, and the president has already agreed to sign it if it passes the Senate. If you vote no, it will fail.

Those who favor the bill cite the following benefits.

It will encourage more people to go to college.
It will result in more diversity on college campuses.
More people will graduate from college.
The economy will benefit from a more educated workforce.

Those opposed cite these negative aspects.

Taxes will need to be raised to pay for this plan.
Those who already paid back their student loans will not get a refund.
Military recruitment may suffer, because tuition benefits will no longer be relevant.
Colleges will probably raise tuition considerably.

The majority rules here, so you must be extra careful as a utilitarian not to abuse that power. You are looking out for the most happiness for the most people, regardless of your personal beliefs.

1. How might the views of the state's people you represent influence your vote? In other words, if the majority were in favor, would you vote in favor of it, too?

2. Would a Kantian vote differently than a utilitarian? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM133671937

Questions Cloud

What is recoup costs from conference attendees : What is the recommended split between sponsor and recoup costs from conference attendees?

Assess a company cash inflows and outflows : How do they help us assess a company's cash inflows and outflows? Share your thoughts on why understanding cash flow dynamics is crucial for decision-making.

Concept of bureaucratic culture : Imagine that you are examining the federal bureaucracy in an attempt to gather evidence in support of James Q. Wilson's concept of bureaucratic culture.

Why is the department of human services budget so large : Why is the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) budget so large?

Would a kantian vote differently than a utilitarian : How might the views of the state's people you represent influence your vote? In other words, if the majority were in favor, would you vote in favor of it, too?

What type of enforcement capabilities would it have : If you could create a new governmental agency designed to address a problem in Texas society, what would be its purpose?

Define the concepts of nationalism and patriotism : Illustrate your understanding of these two concepts by identifying an example of each concept within the context of Canadian society.

Review action planning tool for influencing public policy : Review Action Planning Tool for Influencing Public Policy, Adapted from "The Power of Many: Facilitator's Guide", Program and Training Consultation Centre.

What do you think is the likelihood of a civil war in the us : Discuss 2 to 3 factors that might lead to a civil war or 2-3 factors as to why a civil war is unlikely. Is the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict a civil war?

User Account

All Pages