Will the court rule for peden or the police department

Assignment Help Operation Management

Reference no: EM131933421

Read Case Problem below and post your response to the problem. Will the court rule for Peden or the police department? Why?

(MINIMUM 3 READABLE PARAGRAPHS)

Allan Peden, a Detroit police officer, suffered a heart attack and underwent successful heart surgery. years he continued working in clerical positions with the police department's Crime Analysis Unit (CAU).

The Detroit Police Department decided to update the written job description for police posi- tions based on a list of "24 Essential Job Functions of a Law Enforcement Officer" developed by the Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council.

The list included such tasks as pursuing suspects in foot chases, engaging in vehicle pursuits, effecting forcible arrests, overcoming violent resis- tance, and qualifying with a firearm. The police department described the duties of police officers as including patrolling an assigned post, enforcing laws, apprehending violators of the law, trans- porting sick and injured people to hospitals, and serving warrants.

The police department physicians reviewed Peden's medical records and determined that he was unable to perform the required tasks on the job description. The police department then placed Peden on involuntary disability retirement.

The department claimed that he was incapable of performing the essential functions of a police officer position, but Peden argued that the job description did not accurately reflect the nature of his previous position. Will the court rule for Peden or the police department? Why?

[See Peden v. City of Detroit, 470 Mich. 195, 680 N.W.2d 857 (Mich. 2004).]

Reference no: EM131933421

Questions Cloud

Downturn in the economy in hong kong and china : Given the downturn in the economy in Hong Kong and China, what do you think Prada's future is in the region?

Do you think this percentage is motivating to employees : Do you think you would personally be more motivated by more frequent raises or by performance bonuses if the annual amounts were the same?

Value-based company to a volume-based company : Analysts, however, were of the opinion that P&G had shifted its priority from being a value-based company to a volume-based company, in a bid to take on its riv

Discuss the disadvantages of being part of an incubator : Write two paragraphs about what attracted you to your choice, and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of being part of an incubator.

Will the court rule for peden or the police department : Read Case Problem below and post your response to the problem. Will the court rule for Peden or the police department? Why?

How you would meet their particular needs : You should also mention how often training will occur, what formats you'll use and where you will find good and relevant content for your materials.

What is the optimal decision for rawhide and why : Finally, discuss the differences between your answers above. What is the optimal decision for Rawhide and why?

Is this reasoning consistent with calabresi and melameds : But when a large number of people are involved, so that the nuisance is public, the Court says that the appropriate course is to enjoin the nuisance.

Administrative procedure act intend to remedy : What historical problems did the administrative procedure act intend to remedy?

User Account

All Pages