Why is it a problem to be honest in calvinos story

Assignment Help English
Reference no: EM13649815

At night everybody would leave home with skeleton keys and shaded lanterns and go and burgle a neighbour's house. They'd get back at dawn, loaded, to find their own house had been robbed.

So everybody lived happily together, nobody lost out, since each stole from the other, and that other from another again, and so on and on until you got to a last person who stole from the first. Trade in the country inevitably involved cheating on the parts both of the buyer and the seller. The government was a criminal organization that stole from its subjects, and the subjects for their part were only interested in defrauding the government. Thus life went on smoothly, nobody was rich and nobody was poor.

One day, how we don't know, it so happened that an honest man came to live in the place. At night, instead of going out with his sack and his lantern, he stayed home to smoke and read novels.

The thieves came, saw the light on and didn't go in.

This went on for a while: then they were obliged to explain to him that even if he wanted to live without doing anything, it was no reason to stop others from doing things. Every night he spent at home meant a family would have nothing to eat the following day.

The honest man could hardly object to such reasoning. He took to going out in the evening and coming back the following morning like they did, but he didn't steal. He was honest, there was nothing you could do about it. He went as far as the bridge and watched the water flow by beneath. When he got home he found he had been robbed.

In less than a week the honest man found himself penniless, he had nothing to eat and his house was empty. But this was hardly a problem, since it was his own fault; no, the problem was that his behaviour upset everything else. Because he let the others steal everything he had without stealing anything from anybody; so there was always someone who came home at dawn to find their house untouched: the house he should have robbed. In any event after a while the ones who weren't being robbed found themselves richer than the others and didn't want to steal any more. To make matters worse, the ones who came to steal from the honest man's house found it was always empty; so they became poor.

Meanwhile, the ones who had become rich got into the honest man's habit of going to the bridge at night to watch the water flow by beneath. This increased the confusion because it meant lots of others became rich and lots of others became poor.

Now, the rich people saw that if they went to the bridge every night they'd soon be poor. And they thought: ‘Let's pay some of the poor to go and rob for us.' They made contracts, fixed salaries, percentages: they were still thieves of course, and they still tried to swindle each other. But, as tends to happen, the rich got richer and the poor got poorer and poorer.

Some of the rich people got so rich that they didn't need to steal or have others steal for them so as to stay rich. But if they stopped stealing they would get poor because the poor stole from them. So they paid the very poorest of the poor to defend their property from the other poor, and that meant setting up a police force and building prisons.

So it was that only a few years after the appearance of the honest man, people no longer spoke of robbing and being robbed, but only of the rich and the poor; but they were still all thieves.

The only honest man had been the one at the beginning, and he died in very short order, of hunger.

Question 1:

Why is it a problem to be honest in Calvino's story?

Question 2:

What is the theme of this story?

Reference no: EM13649815

Questions Cloud

What is the main theme of the story : From the short story entitled "The Chaser" written by John Collier, are there any symbols in this story? If so, what are they and to what are they representing?
Determine a common behavioural challenge : Determine a common behavioral challenge in your organization
What is the main purpose of the writer : What is the main conflict: internal or external and what is the main purpose of the writer to write such a story?
Find the volume of the water displaced : A cube floats in water. The length of each side 8 cm. Thecube is 3/4 submerged. Find the volume of the water displaced
Why is it a problem to be honest in calvinos story : Why is it a problem to be honest in Calvino's story and what is the theme of this story
What is your communication modality : What is your communication modality
Evaluate what is the speed of the vehicle : An automobile moves at constant speed over the crest of ahill. The driver moves in a vertical circle of radius 20 m.What is the speed of the vehicle
Estimate what is the actual diameter of the red blood cell : A microscope has an objective lens with a focal length of 16.22 mmand an eyepiece with a focal length of 9.00 mm. what is the actual diameter of the red blood cell
What roles are played by the female characters : Echoes from the Past - What roles are played by the female characters you encountered in this unit? Describe some of these female characters, their traits

Reviews

Write a Review

English Questions & Answers

  Students should pick one or a couple of health behaviors

students should pick one or a couple of health behaviors that they would like to improve at the beginning of the

  Define how see the war on terrorism

Discuss how you see the "war on terrorism" as of this date. Do you think the United States should be engaged in such a war?

  The true value placed on a product or service is the value

1.in the reading for this module author rick newman writes that employees who demonstrate multidisciplinary agility

  Explain in a detail war on terrorism

Discuss how you see the "war on terrorism" as of this date. Do you think the United States should be engaged in such a war? Give reasons for or against this "war"

  Rewrite the report

On physical exam, lungs are clear to percussion and auscultation. Vital signs are stable the patient is afebrile. No lymphadenopathy. Throat is clear mucus membranes are pink and moist.

  Prepare a justification report

Create a plan that identifies what information you will need to prepare a justification report making a recommendation to an organization to implement a particular product, service, or program

  Lesson plan on objective: to learn

Now write a lesson plan for a 45-minute-long lesson with one of the objectives below. (Min 200 words)Objective: to learn and practise the vocabulary of hobbies and to revise adverbs of frequency.

  Desribe health pyschology

This is a two page paper with APA reference please cite the references when quoting. Please last two papers I received a bad grade because of the grammar and content so the reason I used this is because i have five classes and a single parent and ..

  This week you read about the concepts of virtue values and

this week you read about the concepts of virtue values and ethics. one of the key questions when thinking about these

  Means by the phrase libery of society

What do you think he means by the phrase "Libery of Society" and do we see this demonstrated anywhere else in the book?

  Using the librarys catalog the mla database or the jstor

using the librarys catalog the mla database or the jstor database find a book or article addressing a major question or

  One of the children have a helmet for their bicycle

Does this sentence use the correct subject verb agreement "One of the children have a helmet for their bicycle"

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd