Why does elliott think this proposal is problematic

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM133445217

Case Study: Menneskeskapte perfluorerte stoffer - PFAS'er - kalles også evighetskjemikalier, fordi de ikke brytes ned i naturen. PFAS-er brukes i veldig man sammenhenger. For eksempel brukes de som belegg på stekepanner så maten ikke brenner seg fast, til jakker sann at de blir vannavvisende, i mye matemballasje, i noe papir og maling, osv. osv. Samtidig har man blant annet funnet ut at noen PFAS-er forstyrrer immunsystemet og hindrer vaksiner i å fungere best mulig hos barn, og at andre kan gjøre at fosterutvikling hemmes

Questions:

1) Imagine that it is not clear how much evidence is required to accept the hypothesis "any intake of PFASs is harmful to health." According to the argument from inductive risk, a researcher in this situation should first consider the possible consequences of erroneously rejecting the hypothesis and of erroneously accepting it. What could be the possible consequences of wrongly rejecting the PFAS hypothesis and what could be the possible consequences of wrongly accepting it?

2) According to the argument from inductive risk, a researcher should then consider whether it has worse consequences to wrongly reject a hypothesis or to wrongly accept it. If it is worse to falsely reject the hypothesis, the researcher should require less evidence to accept the hypothesis. If it is worse to falsely accept the hypothesis, the researcher should require more evidence to accept the hypothesis. Which mistake would have worse consequences in relation to the PFAS hypothesis? Does this mean that the researcher needs more or less evidence to accept the hypothesis? Remember to justify your answer.

3) According to Elliott, an objection to the argument from inductive risk is that researchers can simply present the evidence to decision-makers and leave it up to them how much evidence is required. In this way, researchers avoid having to decide for themselves how much evidence is required. Why does Elliott think this proposal is problematic and do you agree?

Reference no: EM133445217

Questions Cloud

Why the government needed to sell the people in the war : Why the government needed to sell the people in the war. Then design an effective campaign in no more than a page for rallying people's support.
What are your assumptions about growing older based on : What are your assumptions about growing older based on - facts, myths, or observations? How do you think lookism, sizeism, and healthism will affect some of you
How does the show present its subject matter as authentic : How does the show present its subject matter as authentic or "real?" In what ways has reality in the show been shaped or framed by editing?
Introducing african american and mental illness : Compose a brief statement introducing African American and mental illness. Summarize a related Healthy People 2030 Goal that applies to African American and Men
Why does elliott think this proposal is problematic : researchers avoid having to decide for themselves how much evidence is required. Why does Elliott think this proposal is problematic and do you agree?
Discuss civil defense : Drawing on examples from the film The Atomic Café, discuss civil defense, later abandoned, in the early postwar period.
Evaluate educational, intelligence, career, and personality : How do you define intelligence? Can it be measured? Explain your answer. If you believe intelligence cannot be measured, what would you say about the tests
Spiritual health to prevent from diabetes. : Things you can do for your physical health, mental health, emotional health and spiritual health to prevent from diabetes.
How did slaves produce the souths various crops : What circumstances led to Solomon Northup, a free man, becoming a slave? How did slaves produce the South's various crops?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Calculate the random access memory

Calculate the random access memory (RAM) in megabytes necessary to store a multidimensional array that is 20 × 40 × 120.

  What role do you believe that stress can play

What role do you believe that stress can play in contributing to the development of a psychological disorder? Please describe how you believe stress contribute

  Identify the practical nurse role in disaster preparedness

Identify the Practical Nurse's role in disaster preparedness. How the medical team members will work together to provide care

  Discuss how external and internal evidence influenced

External and Internal EvidenceWhen interpreting historical data, why is it important to look at both external and internal evidence?

  How is sexual motivation influenced by cultural factors

Do you agree or disagree with Maslow's theory and his hierarchy of needs concept? Why or why not? Do you think there is any variation to the order of these needs within our own culture or among various cultures?

  How would you approach the physician

How would you approach the physician. What is the impact to patients? What are the contingency plans for unavailable items

  Analyze through the concept of global village

Create a 5slide Microsoft® PowerPoint® or Prezi presentation in which you present the major concepts of the global village.

  Discuss the influence of american music on world music

RESEARCH ON THE WEB - ESSAY: Discuss the influence of American Music on World Music, the influence of World Music on American Music and how the transistor radio effected this cross pollination.(NOTE: World Music is a style and category of music, y..

  Write a synopsis of the buffalo creek disaster book

Write a synopsis of "The Buffalo Creek Disaster" book. What is your personal reaction to the outcome of the Buffalo Creek Disaster case? Be specific. Tell us why

  Develop a marketing plan for a healthcare facility

Please develop a marketing plan for a healthcare facility that was recently cited by the OIG (Office of Inspector General), or has been investigated by a journalist

  What are some strengths that have allowed constitution

What are some of the strengths that have allowed the Constitution to survive the test of time? Basically, why is the U.S. Constitution still around where other.

  How can we effectively manage emotions at work

How can we effectively manage emotions at work? A salesperson with intense passion can convince someone to make a purchase

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd