Why can the ombudsman directly review the ministers decision

Reference no: EM133244232

Assignment:

Below are two scenarios that raise issues about the the relationship between the exercise of executive powers and their oversight, and foundational concepts studied in Government and Public Law. Please consider the scenarios set out below and answer the related questions.

a. In a press conference, Chidinma Ibrahim, a reporter for Guardian Australia, noted recent news stories chronicling the Health Minister's rejection of applications from retail workers working in 'non-essential' retail stores for a determination that they are authorised workers under the Human Biosecurity (Stay at Home Requirements) Order 2020 (Cth). She asked the Prime Minister, Ara Margossian, why the Health Minister had been given such a wide power to limit who could leave their homes to go to work. Mr Margossian admitted that there was little evidence to suggest that retail workers going to work in a workplace where retail customers could only 'click and collect' items was a source of spread of COVID-19. However, he said: 'not only will the Minister receive what she wants in terms of additional powers or additional resources, but more than what she needs or wants'. Explain why this statement is inconsistent with:

i. constitutionalism; and

ii. TRS Allan's definition of the rule of law.

b. Maya Krishnan lives alone. She is really worried about getting lonely and the impact it will have on her mental health if there is no way for someone to come and visit her at home while the order is in place. She writes to the Commonwealth Ombudsman asking them to conduct a review into the Minister's decision not to include a 'social bubble' in the list of reasonable excuses for leaving your place of residence under

Part of the Human Biosecurity (Stay at Home Requirements) Order 2020 (Cth).

i. Can the Ombudsman directly review the Minister's decision? Why or why not?

ii. The Ombudsman is limited to making non-binding recommendations for the government to consider. Is this a reflection of political constitutionalism? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM133244232

Questions Cloud

Discuss three problems associated with teams : List each question, then follow with your answer. Answer all parts of the question. Cite sources, both in-line and in summary. Suppose you are put in charge of

Summarizing the key stakeholders for the project : Search the Internet and scan IT industry magazines or websites to find an example of an IT project that had problems due to organizational issues. Write a short

Literature review section for five articles : Can you write a literature review of the problem of gun violence that addresses 5 peer-reviewed journal articles. The review of each journal article must contai

Business key measures of competitiveness : Describe the application of the business' key measures of competitiveness (such as the former DTI's seven measures: delivered right first time, delivery schedul

Why can the ombudsman directly review the ministers decision : The Ombudsman is limited to making non-binding recommendations for the government to consider. Is this a reflection of political constitutionalism?

Development of the zte corporation command : I recently worked on the development of the ZTE Corporation's Command Center, a security facility in the nation. According to Grace (2021), the use of key perfo

Virtual project environments : Explain what you thought were the most important or significant steps organizations can do to sustain their virtual project environments. Provide examples and s

Describe megans law means in pa : Visit the Megan's Law website for PA. In a one to two page essay, describe what Megan's law means in PA. Who needs to register and for how long?

Challenge and opportunity of promoting clean energy solution : Please include a page summary of this article and then recommendations on how the issue could have been managed differently.

User Account

All Pages