Whom do you think the jury will favor

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133198055

Case: Hahane, as an individual, had an option to purchase a valuable piece of land for $500,000, provided she exercised the option by a certain date by mailing a deposit check for $50,000. This land was appraised at $600,000 and she intended to build housing for her family and her elderly mother on it. She drew a check for $50,000 on her personal checking account she had at First American Bank and mailed it to the landowner. Hahane had this checking account for 10 years. At the time she drew the check, she verified electronically that she had $60,000 in this personal account. However the LLC, HELPING HAND, LLC, of which she was one of two members, owed the bank $30,000 for a loan collateralized with the LLC's assets.. That loan was 60 days overdue. That loan had been taken out two years ago. The bank refused to honor the $50,000 check and spent $750.00 handling the resulting paperwork. As a result of the dishonorment, Hahane's option became void, and the landowner sold the land to someone else for $550,000, resulting in a severe loss to Hahane. She sued the bank for damages.

The Trial

At trial, Hahane's attorneys proved the value of the land, her losses, and the fact that she had always paid the bank on time, The LLC's business payment was overdue. The bank's attorneys proved that the LLC was over sixty days late on the last LLC loan payment and that it was their not their practice to notify customers that there might be insufficient funds in their accounts to cover all checks written, as doing so would place an undue burden on the banking system.

The Arguments at Trial

Hahane's attorneys argued that a bank has no right to dishonor a check except for the normal reasons permitted by law, such as a suspected forgery, an improper endorsement, and so forth. They further argued that the bank, based on its relationship with Hahane, should have contacted her before dishonoring the check so that she could have taken other action to prevent her loss of the land and that she did not have an automatic deduction from her personal account for the LLC's loan. The bank's attorneys argued that Hahane's being overdue on her last loan payment indicated she was in financial trouble, that they had a right to seize her account to cover the overdue payment, and that instead they simply refused to honor checks on her account until the overdue loan was paid. They further argued that based on banking industry customs, it is the responsibility of the customer and not the bank to make sure there are sufficient funds to cover checks written. They were losing money each day that the loan was unpaid.

Question 1: Whom do you think the jury will favor, Hahane or the bank? Why?

Question 2: If you feel Hahane should win, what will her damages be? If you feel the bank should win, what will their damages be?

Question 3: Under what circumstances, if any, should a bank be able to offset a loan to a customer against any bank account on which the customer's name appears?

Reference no: EM133198055

Questions Cloud

Create a compensation package for a new expatriate position : Using the Compensation and Benefits Template as a guide, create a compensation package for a new expatriate position

Calculate time-weighted average noise exposure : BOS 4301 - Columbian Southern University - Calculate the 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) noise exposure for each of the three workers.

How does the choice of a service level affect : How does the choice of a service level affect the other choices that a retailer makes, such as price, product line selection, size of store, and location?

Genetic consequences of observed trait or conditions : Explanation of the genetic consequences of the observed trait or conditions.

Whom do you think the jury will favor : Cuyamaca College - what circumstances, if any, should a bank be able to offset a loan to a customer against any bank account on which the customer's name

Explain the politics-administration dichotomy : Explain in your own words the politics-administration dichotomy. Describe what you can infer about the dichotomy (ideas of practice vs. theory)

Should considerations of fairness : BUS 125 Cuyamaca College - Should considerations of fairness and the intentions of the person making the will take precedence over a validly executed will?

How many protons and neutrons does carbon twelve have : How many protons and neutrons does Carbon 12 have? What about Carbon 14? How do scientists use radioactivity to determine how old something is?

Develop a benefits plan for all employees : You have been tasked to develop benefits plan for all employees, which appeals most to assembly-line workers since they comprise highest percentage of employees

User Account

All Pages