Who is the best person qualified to make functional estimate

Assignment Help Project Management
Reference no: EM131860281

Assignment

Case Study: CAPITAL INDUSTRIES

In the summer of 1976, Capital Industries undertook a material development programto see if a hard-plastic bumper could be developed for medium-sized cars.By January 1977, Project Bumper (as it was called by management) had developeda material that endured all preliminary laboratory testing.

One more step was required before full-scale laboratory testing: a three-dimensional stress analysis on bumper impact collisions. The decision to performthe stress analysis was the result of a concern on the part of the technical communitythat the bumper might not perform correctly under certain conditions. Thecost of the analysis would require corporate funding over and above the originalestimates. Since the current costs were identical to what was budgeted, the additionalfunding was a necessity.

Frank Allen, the project engineer in the Bumper Project Office, was assignedcontrol of the stress analysis. Frank met with the functional manager of the engineeringanalysis section to discuss the assignment of personnel to the task.

Functional manager: "I'm going to assign Paul Troy to this project. He's a newman with a Ph.D. in structural analysis. I'm sure he'll do well."

Frank Allen: "This is a priority project. We need seasoned veterans, not newpeople, regardless of whether or not they have Ph.D.s. Why not use some otherproject as a testing ground for your new employee?"

Functional manager: "You project people must accept part of the responsibilityfor on-the-job training. I might agree with you if we were talking about bluecollarworkers on an assembly line. But this is a college graduate, coming to uswith a good technical background."

FrankAllen: "He may have a good background, but he has no experience. He needssupervision. This is a one-man task. The responsibility will be yours if he fouls up."

Functional manager: "I've already given him our book for cost estimates. I'msure he'll do fine. I'll keep in close communication with him during the project."

Frank Allen met with Paul Troy to get an estimate for the job.

Paul Troy: "I estimate that 800 hours will be required."

Frank Allen: "Your estimate seems low. Most three-dimensional analyses requireat least 1,000 hours. Why is your number so low?"

Paul Troy: "Three-dimensional analysis? I thought that it would be a two-dimensionalanalysis. But no difference; the procedures are the same. I canhandle it."

Frank Allen: "O.K. I'll give you 1,100 hours. But if you overrun it, we'll bothbe sorry."

Frank Allen followed the project closely. By the time the costs were 50 percentcompleted, performance was only 40 percent. A cost overrun seemed inevitable.The functional manager still asserted that he was tracking the job andthat the difficulties were a result of the new material properties. His section hadnever worked with materials like these before.

Six months later Troy announced that the work would be completed in oneweek, two months later than planned. The two-month delay caused major problemsin facility and equipment utilization. Project Bumper was still paying foremployees who were "waiting" to begin full-scale testing.

On Monday mornings, the project office would receive the weekly labormonitor report for the previous week. This week the report indicated that the publicationsand graphics art department had spent over 200 man-hours (last week)in preparation of the final report. Frank Allen was furious. He called a meetingwith Paul Troy and the functional manager.

Frank Allen: "Who told you to prepare a formal report? All we wanted was ago or no-go decision as to structural failure."

Paul Troy: "I don't tum in any work unless it's professional. This report will bedocumented as a masterpiece."

Frank Allen: "Your 50 percent cost overrun will also be a masterpiece. I guessyour estimating was a little off!"

Paul Troy: "Well, this was the first time that I had performed a three-dim dimensionalstress analysis. And what's the big deal? I got the job done, didn't IT'

Questions:

1. Who is the best person qualified to make functional estimates?
2. Can this task be delegated?
3. Should the estimating of this task have been delegated?
4. Should Paul Troy have been delegated the responsibility for theestimate?
5. Should Frank Allen have sensed a communication problem between Paul Troy and the functional manager?
6. Should Frank Allen have tracked the project more closely because of the above-mentioned problems?
7. Does Paul Troy appear to realize that there are also time and cost constraints on a project?
8. Is it beneficial for project office personnel to know the man­ hour estimates?

Reference no: EM131860281

Questions Cloud

Supervising the employees of its subsidiaries : Was Union Carbide Corporation responsible for training and supervising the employees of its subsidiaries?
Explain how does logistics fit into a supply chain model : Explain How does logistics fit into a supply chain model? In general, should LUML be looking at the possible use of Supply Chain Facilitators?
How are the risks of foreign investment in a plant : How are the risks of foreign investment in a plant or production facility greater than those associated with exporting or licensing?
Chemical properties of volatile organic compounds : What are the other chemical properties of Volatile Organic Compounds that make them an especially potent class of toxic chemicals?
Who is the best person qualified to make functional estimate : Who is the best person qualified to make functional estimates? Should Paul Troy have been delegated the responsibility for theestimate?
Purchase fractional amounts of goods : Mona's preferences for food, F, and clothing, C, are derived by a utility function U(F,C)=FC. Food costs $1 a unit and clothing costs $2 a unit.
Write the equation for petra budget line : Write the equation for Petra's budget line.
Provide definition of opportunity cost : Discuss what the opportunity cost of attending college is for you, noting that the concepts of opportunity costs and explicit monetary costs are not the same.
Discuss about the marketing plan and sales strategy : This assignment consists of two (2) sections: a marketing plan and sales strategy, and a marketing budget. Note: You must submit both sections as separate.

Reviews

Write a Review

Project Management Questions & Answers

  Create a project schedule and align resources

Create a project schedule and align resources, Analyze project schedule and resource allocation

  Managerial roles and gap analysis

Write a report on Managerial Roles and Gap Analysis

  Questionaire on project management

Questionaire on Project Management

  Describe the market growth rate for product

Describe the market growth rate for product and service.

  Prepare a work plan and project schedule - gantt chart

Design an online system for the human resources department to manage available job positions.

  Project risk management approach

How does a project risk management approach pro-vide an early warning signal for impending problems or issues

  Black-scholes options pricing model

Calculate the payoff and the profits for investments

  Describe the features or characteristics of product

Describe the features or characteristics of your product or service.

  Write paper on inventory management system

Write paper on Inventory Management System.

  Analysis of the overall project risk

Analysis of the overall project risk

  Investment and performance analysis

Evaluate the usefulness of ROCE

  Distribution strategy and project management

Distribution strategy and project management

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd