Who has the stronger arguments

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM133191726 , Length: 3 pages

Case: You're on the Jury : The Case of the Politically Incorrect Sign

Disturbed by the number and variety of signs that individuals were putting up within its borders, a City passed an ordinance prohibiting all signs on private property except in commercial areas for advertising. Sam, a homeowner, pasted a sign on the front door of his house containing an American flag with these words underneath the flag: "Down with the Mayor and the City Council - Our rights are being violated". He then went door to door in his neighborhood passing out copies of this sign and asking his neighbors to display it as well. Sam was arrested for violating the ordinance.

The Trial

During the trial, a witness for the City described how many signs had appeared in the past on homes and on lawns for commercial home businesses, ruining the appearance of the community. He explained that many other cities and towns had experienced the same problems and that the ordinance was reasonable and the only way to solve the problem. The restriction, he said, was content neutral as it was addressing a societal problem. Sam testified that the sign he had put up was a small one and that other City residents had raised flags on national holidays and put up signs showing their patriotism. None of these residents had been arrested.

The Arguments at Trial

The City's attorney argued that a city had the authority to regulate signs within its borders to protect the appearance and value of properties. She further argued that the ordinance did not unduly restrict free speech as there were other ways for residents to express their views: radio, television, and the newspapers. Sam's attorney argued that the regulation violated the freedom of speech provisions of the federal constitution, was too broad, too vague, and was unreasonable. He argued that the City could have limited the ordinance by restricting signs over a certain size and in certain locations. He further argued that it was unreasonable to restrict the expression of opinions except for the use of the media.

Question 1: Who has the stronger arguments, the City or Sam? Why?

Question 2: What are the laws here that are being applied and is their application proper?

Question 3: If you were the on the jury hearing this case, for whom would you decide? Why?

Reference no: EM133191726

Questions Cloud

How do the intellectual traits assist in the process : What attributes are associated with being a fair-minded thinker? How do the intellectual traits assist in this process? (Paul & Elder, 2013)?
Replace the disinfectants and why or why not : Florida State University - Analyze and explain whether Clean should be required to replace the disinfectants and why or why not. You must consider and apply
What are the physical and mental effects of stress : What are the physical and mental effects of stress? What is psychological resilience, and why is it so important? (consider pathophysiology and coping skills)
Identify and explain perspectives of children within study : Identify and explain the perspectives of children/young people within the study. Debate the impact of ideas about ‘globalisation' on this topic.
Who has the stronger arguments : California College San Diego - You're on the Jury : The Case of the Politically Incorrect Sign - What are the laws here that are being applied
What other ways cumulative effects assessments be modified : What other ways can cumulative effects assessments be modified or improved to ensure the highest environmental protection?
What is an example of an effective work group in health care : What is an example of an effective work group in health care? Why is this important? Provide details
Different types of mergers in details : Law 401 Saudi electronic university - Write down and explain the advantages and disadvantages for shareholders in the control group.
Describe environmental impact from development of resource : Describe an environmental impact (or potential environmental impact) from development (or potential development) of the resource base of your community.

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Legal environment of business caselet

The assignment in Law deals with the topic "Legal Environment of Business". A case study about Mary, a newly joined employee who is working in the USA and Europe. She faces few issues at her work place in Europe and tries to talk to her manager who s..

  Business ethics & legal issues caselet

This assignment is about the concept of Business Ethics & Legal Issues. The laws relating to these can be found in Antitrust laws. These laws are concerned with those large corporations which have a majority of market share, mergers and acquisitions.

  Questions on business law and ethics

Examples of securities that are exempted from the registration provisions of the 1933 Act and involving misstatement of material facts in a prospectus.

  Discuss the doctrine of ratification of pre-incorporation

With the aid of a decided cases, discuss the doctrine of ratification of pre-incorporation contract.

  Discuss the extent of phoenixing activity

It has been estimated that about 6,000 phoenix companies operate in Australia, costing government and the community hundreds of millions of dollars per year and impacting on individuals.

  Application of law to facts

Company Law, Application of Law to Facts and Conclusion.

  Question on business law and ethics

This assignment related to business law.

  Questions on business law

Answer all the questions under business law.

  Iidentify the issue raised by the facts

Iidentify the issue(s) raised by the facts, identify the relevant legal principles, apply the relevant legal principles to the facts, reach a conclusion.

  Evaluation of software development

Prepare a report and present an evaluation of the subsequent methodologies for software development in terms of cost, resources and time.

  Business value and ethics

Business value and ethics,  Bart agrees to put Sam's Super Bowl champion-ship autographed football in his sports store to sell for $1,500. Sam agrees to pay Bart a 15% commission for selling the ball. If Joe comes in the sports store and offers Bart ..

  Explain what is meant by income by ordinary concepts

Advise what tax consequences arise in respect of the payments.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd