What you know about this new president

Assignment Help Case Study
Reference no: EM131365425

Select one of the questions about each case to respond to thoroughly

Case: Lying to Rachel Adams

Purpose:
The purpose of this case study is to develop a deeper understanding of how the ethical principles discussed this unit can affect individuals and the organization.

Situation:
Rachel Adams was very marketable. Job opportunities were excellent for someone with her computer-related skills. During one week in October three headhunters had contacted her trying to woo her away from her present position at Ballinger Systems. However, Adams liked her job, was compensated well, and had just bought a new home with her husband that was within a fifteen-minute drive of her Ballinger office. Adams's husband was happily employed. With their two incomes, life was very comfortable. Adams was a computer design specialist, and part of her responsibilities involved managing other such specialists. She had an MBA, and when she was initially hired by Ballinger Systems she had four other job opportunities. Rachel Adams decided not to encourage the headhunters. Times were good; if they turned bad she figured she could
still get another job easily.

Times did turn bad. The next November, just thirteen months later, Ballinger Systems' stock was plummeting. Not only was her company's stock plummeting, but so was the stock of several other similar organizations. Through the grapevine Adams heard that Ballinger was considering merging with a competitor. Adams set up a meeting with her superior, Janet, to ask if there were, in fact, merger talks. Her superior assured her that there were no such conversations. As far as she knew, claimed the boss, Ballinger would be independent forever. "l promise you, Rachel, we're not going anywhere."

This was reassuring to Rachel Adams. She was no longer as marketable as she had been. Nevertheless, one headhunter had very recently contacted her. The job he proposed was for a similar position in a nearby location. Rachel and her husband could stay in their home. The salary was a little less than what she was making with Ballinger, but the new company would, certainly, not be going anywhere. They were a major player and were not about to be merging. The headhunter reminded Rachel that times were not like they used to be. Adams, of course, knew this. The headhunter also commented about the possible merger of Ballinger that Adams herself had heard through the grapevine. "Consider this opportunity, Rachel. Listen to me. Times are not good and they will get worse. Anything could happen. I know you'll get this job l've lined up for you."

Adams weighed the idea of applying for the other job and decided against it. Janet had assured her that the merger talks were nothing but hyperactive grapevine rumors. She wanted to stay put and decided to do so. Her subordinates, who had also heard of the possible merger, asked Rachel about it. "Look," she told them, "l was concerned, but I was assured by Janet that there will be no merger. Janet told me this point blank and I believe her."

In January, all employees at Ballinger received a happy mailing announcing the successful merger with Wellburton, lnc. Adams quickly set up a meeting with her superior. Janet apologized but said she had been under strict orders not to comment on any of the merger negotiations.

"l thought we had a good relationship. I trusted you."

"Look Rachel. I work for Ballinger. I have to be concerned for Ballinger. lf I tell you about the merger, you might jump ship. lf you jump ship, others might leave. This could jeopardize our day-to-day operations and also might make it difficult for us to close on this merger. You may think I had a moral obligation to tell you the truth, but I have a moral obligation to Ballinger to do my job. In this case doing my job means keeping you here. Keeping you here requires that I omit certain information."

"Omit certain information? You promised! You said, 'l promise you, Rachel, we're not going anywhere.' That's what you said."

"l didn't lie. We're not going anywhere. There will be some downsizing as obviously there will be duplication of responsibilities with the merger. However, Wellburton and their people are moving in here. We're not going anywhere. I didn't lie."

Adams was incredulous. She nearly screamed, "l cannot believe you would do this."

"Welcome to the real world."

"You know I told my subordinates that there would be no merger. I trusted you. I told them I trusted you. What should I tell them now?"

"Tell them what I just told you."

In February, one month later, Rachel Adams lost her position at Ballinger-Wellburton.

Questions:

1. Did Ballinger administrators have a responsibility to honestly inform all employees about the proposed merger?

2. Does Adams have a legitimate reason to be upset or is she responsible for her own predicament since she did not pursue the job that the headhunter had presented to her?

3. Janet claimed that she did not lie when she made her promise. Did she lie?

4. Which ethical guidelines came to play in this situation? Do you think the company will face any consequences for its behavior?

Case: The "Communication President"

Purpose:
The purpose of this case study is to develop a deeper understanding of how the communication process operates in an organizational context.

Situation:
A grocery store chain recently appointed a new president. You are the communication specialist in the organization, which has 18 departments and 350 employees. The second day on the job, the president called you into her office, where a picture of T.S. Eliot was prominently displayed among a disarray of papers and files. She warmly greeted you and said that she wanted to "kick around a few ideas". She told you that she wants to be known as the "Communication President". She wants you to devise a "talking proclamation-- - - kind of like the Ten Commandments, my Magna Carta" for the employees that demonstrates her commitment to effective communication. She relayed the following:

Here's my idea. I want everyone to feel free to discuss anything with me or anyone else. I would like to foster an open climate here. I'd like to draft a statement of my communication principles. For instance, we could say something like: "Effective communication is the basis for an effective organization." No, I like this better: "I believe effective communication is the basis for an effective organization." You get the idea? Then we could list some principles like:

We believe in an open-door policy.
Communication should always be frank.
It's important to keep all employees apprised of relevant information.
Address everyone by his or her first name.
Make sure you thoroughly understand someone before criticizing his/her ideas.
Always listen first, talk second.
Even if you think you understand someone, check to make sure.
Be sensitive to others.
Be open to new ideas.
That should give you a feel for what I'm trying to do. Since you are the communication expert, you can revise these ideas and get back to me with a specific proposal.

Questions:

1. For your initial posting to this discussion, create a specific proposal to make to the President (a document identifying the new President's vision of what effective communication looks like) with suggestions about how to use the document and when and how get it to organizational stakeholders. Be sure to provide a rationale for your suggestions that illustrates your understanding of the material from this unit. For subsequent postings, discuss the statements others have posted-what are the advantages, disadvantages of the way things are phrased or justified, how could individual statements be improved? For subsequent postings also discuss similarities in the statements- what are the key elements that should be included in this statement based on what we've learned?

2. How you would approach the president about the ethical considerations of creating a description of appropriate communication? What would you say to her? Be sure to incorporate material from this unit's readings and lectures in your answer. For subsequent postings, discuss what others have offered-where are the similarities, differences - what are the strengths and weaknesses of each suggestion?

3. From what you know about this new president and the organization, what do you think is the likelihood that such a communication Magna Carta will influence the communication and the organization?

Reference no: EM131365425

Questions Cloud

What was the holding of griswold . connecticut : What was the holding (the central decision) of Griswold v. Connecticut?What were the arguments of the two attorneys in Roe v. Wade? Was Griswold used as precedent in Roe? What was the issue (legal question before the court) in Planned Parenthood of S..
Drafting the contract for a large project : You have been asked to assist the contract manager of a seller organization in drafting the contract for a large project with limited scope clarity. What type of contract would you suggest, such that your organizations does not incur any financial..
Best way to manage stakeholders : What is the best way to manage stakeholders who are extremely supportive and have a high level of interest in the project, but do not have a large influence on the project?
What is the critical issue : 1. What is the critical issue? 2. What can be done about it? 3. Can excellence in project management still be achieved and, if so, how? Whatsteps would you recommend?
What you know about this new president : Develop a deeper understanding of how the ethical principles discussed this unit can affect individuals and the organization - From what you know about this new president and the organization, what do you think is the likelihood that such a communic..
Shortlisted ones and awarding a contract : You are in the process of selecting a seller from the shortlisted ones and awarding a contract. The process will involve receiving bid, or proposals, and applying defined selection criteria to select the seller(s) who is(are) qualified to perform ..
Summarize the youth victimization : Summarize the "Youth Victimization: Prevalence and Implications" report. In your assignment, discuss the strengths and weaknesses of this study. Do you agree with the findings of this report? Why or why not?
Discussion-managing stakeholders : Discuss ways that you have seen people manage stakeholder engagement in your classroom or work environments. Which approaches seem to work the best?
Describe sociological perspectives in the schmalleger text : To increase your knowledge of the field, choose three (3) publicized criminal acts. Describe and discuss how each of the three key sociological perspectives in the Schmalleger text explains the commission of the respective criminal act. Each crimi..

Reviews

Write a Review

Case Study Questions & Answers

  From the scenario, prioritize the attributes of golds reling

From the scenario, prioritize the attributes of Golds Reling's brand from the brand map presented in the scenario according to the attributes that you believe would be most important to the new tablet's target market. Provide support for your respons..

  Discuss critically infosys current and future strategy

Discuss critically Infosys current and future strategy. What advice would you give Kris Gopalakrishnan and KShop has resulted in information overload among staff. What operational measures would you suggest to overcome such challenges?

  Review tarmac business case for diversity

Review Tarmac's Business Case for Diversity and the Learning Resources. Think about Tarmac's approach to managing diversity and how it relates to organisational behaviour concepts and human resource processes.

  Enron case shared activity

Enron was the first nationwide natural gas pipeline network in the United States. As the company grew, executives shifted the company's primary focus from energy delivery and infrastructure to investing in the stock market.

  Ebay inc internet success or fairy tale

Read the case study "eBay Inc.: Internet Success or Fairy Tale? "and answer the question below,   Use the 2002 financial statement data to replicate the Meyer's report calculations that illustrate the conclusion based on the 2001 data reached in the ..

  Mintendo game girl case study

Which option delivers the maximum profit for the supply chain: Sandra's plan, Bill's plan, or no promotion plan at all? How does the answer change if a discount of $10 must be given to reach the same level of impact that the $5 discount received?

  Splash soft drinks case study

Splash Soft Drinks Inc. (SSD) has recently achieved sales that exceeded its expectations after it introduced a new beverage that was greatly welcomed by their customers. The company is currently considering opening a new plant to which some of the pr..

  Details of the task using tesco plc

Details of the task Using Tesco plc (www.tesco.com) as a case study, prepare a report of no more than 2,500 words that:

  What are the common manifestations of alcoholic cirrhosis

What are the common manifestations of alcoholic cirrhosis? Which of these are secondary to hepatocellular failure? Which are secondary to portal hypertension?

  Judge the extent to which the marketing plan at just us

From the case study, judge the extent to which the marketing plan at Just Us! is outdated. Propose two (2) ways that Just Us! could improve the customer experience and thus sustain future growth.

  Read natasha kingery case and answer the questions

Read the DATA CASE on pages 126-127 about Natasha Kingery who is considering furthering her education and is seeking financial advice. Determine the interest rate she is currently earning on her inheritance by going to Yahoo!

  Identify the relevant facts of the case study

Imagine you are the financial controller of XYZ Ltd a corporation that is a very large donor to HOHO. You have recently become aware that its TV advertising has resulted in the charity violating the 25% expenditure ratio for its charity drive.    Id..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd