What would you do in the Bystander at the Switch scenario

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133215085

Assignment - Irvine Moral Theories Discussion

Description - Respond to one of these prompts and be clear about which one you are referring to:

PROMPT 1: MORAL THEORIES. Which of the three moral theories discussed in lecture -- utilitarianism (Mill), deontology (Kant), and virtue ethics (Aristotle) -- do you support? Explain your answer. Could these theories be combined?

PROMPT 2: TECHNOLOGICAL INSTRUMENTALISM. Kevin Kelly (founder of Wired magazine) claims that no technology is ever completely out of bounds. Having a new technology is always an unalloyed good. It is always better to have a new technology at our disposal and simply seek to manage it properly. Do you agree with Kevin Kelly? Explain your answer.

PROMPT 3: RISK ASSESSMENT. "Cost-benefit analysis is designed as a method of quantification, so it surely is better able to deal with more quantifiable aspects of the issues it confronts. But this limitation is in itself ethically neutral unless it can be shown that the quantifiable considerations systematically push decisions in a particular direction. Its detractors must show that the errors of cost-benefit analysis are systematically unjust or ineffective - for example, that it frequently helps the rich at the expense of the poor, or despoils the environment to the benefit of industry, or vice versa." (Leonard & Zeckhauser 1983: 8). Do you agree with this position? Explain your answer.

PROMPT 4: ROBOT PERSONS. Should we allow robots to become moral agents and thus persons? Explain your answer.

PROMPT 5: MORAL RESPONSIBILITY. When there are crashes involving driverless cars, who should be held responsible? Explain your answer.

PROMPT 6: TROLLEY PROBLEM. What would you do in the Bystander at the Switch scenario? (A) Throw the switch in order to maximize well-being (five people surviving is greater than one.) (B) Not throw the switch because that would be a form of killing, and killing is inherently wrong. Explain and defend your answer.

Reference no: EM133215085

Questions Cloud

How are electrons re-energized in photosystem : How are electrons re-energized in photosystem I? What is the role of these two re-energized electrons ultimately?

Explain the Turing Test : Explain the Turing Test. Is the Turing Test a valid test for intelligence? If not, what is the Turing Test a test for? How could the Turing Test be improved

What would the negative consequences be : What are some tasks in your life that you know you have to do but can't find fulfillment in and How are others around you positively affected when you perform

What are the chemical components of item : What are the chemical components of item? What scientific research and development went into creating this item? What has its impact been to culture

What would you do in the Bystander at the Switch scenario : What would you do in the Bystander at the Switch scenario? (A) Throw the switch in order to maximize well-being (five people surviving is greater than one.)

How can we determine the osmolarity : How can we determine the osmolarity of the vegetable tissue - Will the main direction of water movement into the vegetable, out of the vegetable

What would be expected of the results of the tests : A 50 ML EDTA tube is received in the laboratory containing only 1.5 ml of blood. what would be expected of the results of the tests

Identify the ethical and legal implications for a business : Management Case Law Analysis - Identify the ethical and legal implications for a business that were suggested by the court's decision

Define a process to automate student registration : Define a process to automate student registration for an upcoming university career fair event.

User Account

All Pages