What would the consequentialist tell you to do and why

Reference no: EM133552571

Problem

Essay Prompt

Imagine that are the sheriff in a town which has just suffered a terrible crime- ten people have been murdered. You meet with your staff, and they explain that due to internet rumors, everyone in the town believes that Phillip committed the murders. You know this is not true, since you saw Phillip playing at the basketball court, alone, at the time the murders took place. Unfortunately, no one believes you. The townspeople demand that you execute Phillip for the murders tonight or else they will riot.

Assume the following are all true: (a) if you do not execute Phillip tonight, the riot will definitely take place; (b) many innocent people will die as a result (e.g. they'll be trampled, fights will break out, etc.); and (c) the only way to prevent the riot - and thus, to prevent many innocent people from dying - is to execute Phillip tonight.

Task

With all of this in mind, answer the following questions: What would the consequentialist tell you to do, and why? Do you agree with the consequentialist? Why or why not?

Consequentialism: Theory of action that says you should always act in a way that maximizes overall intrinsic goodness and minimizes overall.

Reference no: EM133552571

Questions Cloud

What did you notice with the comic strip on the left : What did you notice with the comic strip on the left? How can you relate to this act? Why? About you trash some garbage anywhere.

Identify two myths that you will use to make a comparison : Identify two myths that you will use to make a comparison. Compare how the two myths imagine the relationship between humans and nature.

Explain each of the symbols on the allegory of the cave : Can you plz explain each of the symbols on the allegory of the cave and argue what they can be in a modern context has to be a long explanation on each only

Describe the three types of friendship aristotle discusses : Describe the three types of friendship Aristotle discusses in Nicomachean Ethics, Book VIII (page119- 137). Next, compare and contrast them.

What would the consequentialist tell you to do and why : What would the consequentialist tell you to do, and why? Do you agree with the consequentialist? Why or why not?

Discuss two films and consider role that music has played : Discuss two films and consider the role that music has played in them. What importance does the music have in the film? Did it change the impact of any scenes?

What does the way the conflict is resolved tell you about : How does the conflict relate to this topic? How is this conflict resolved? If not resolved, why? What does the way the conflict is resolved tell you about

Describe what is meant by wet work and list the tasks : Describe what is meant by wet work and list the tasks associated with wet working What is meant by the term wet work?

What does peter singer think the right thing to do is : What does Peter Singer think 'the right thing to do' is? Do you agree with him? Why or why not? If you agree with him explain - in your own words.

User Account

All Pages