What was the wests biggest failure in afghanistan

Reference no: EM133315182

Assignment: Pretend that you are a foreign policy adviser to a United States Senator on the Foreign Relations Committee Write up a short executive summary on what the following quotes mean in relation to Afghanistan policy.

"What was the West's biggest failure in Afghanistan? Rory Stewart [a British diplomat argues] 'the West always lacked the knowledge, power, or legitimacy to fundamentally transform Afghanistan.'"

"Afghanistan's central problem [is] Afghanistan itself... If you define the modern nation-state as the laying down of permanent borders, and the attempt to establish an extensive state bureaucracy and to invest that bureaucracy with novel forms of authority and control."

"Stanley McChrystal, former commander of coalition forces in Afghanistan, says the U.S. and its NATO allies are only "a little better than" halfway to achieving their military goals, partly due to a "frighteningly simplistic" understanding of the country. "We didn't know enough, and we still don't know enough...Most of us - me included - had a very superficial understanding of the situation and history, and we had a frighteningly simplistic view of recent history, the last 50 years."

Reference no: EM133315182

Questions Cloud

Thoughts and perspective on this paragraph : the statement of cash flows are statements that shows where the cash is flowing in and out of a company. Thoughts and perspective on this paragraph

Describe the role of the manager in the management : Argues about the benefits and challenges derived from the subcontracting (outsourcing) of employees and the relocation of a process (offshoring) of the company

What are of positive and negative effects of our two-party : What are some of the positive and negative effects of our two-party system in the United States? Based on this list of pros and cons, do you think our party

Differences between military and game theory : differences and similarities between the military, game theory, and economic perspectives of strategy. How can each perspective be useful in organizations

What was the wests biggest failure in afghanistan : What was the West's biggest failure in Afghanistan? Rory Stewart [a British diplomat argues] 'the West always lacked the knowledge, power, or legitimacy

How could we improve literacy rates in cps schools : The Chicago Public School system has been blamed for its failure to achieve adequate rates of student literacy. Would providing more resources to schools

Identify and discuss the main research philosophy applicable : Identify and discuss the main research philosophy applicable to the above study conducted by Mukwevho et al (2020). Be sure to explain whether the chosen

How do we test for environmental contamination : How do we test for environmental contamination? Be specific. Please list different methods and cite sources.

What is the best overview for this case : Daniel was offended and worried that the company might be compromised if he could not continue to woo the customer. Why didn't Jack understand

User Account

All Pages