What was the primary basis for the chief justices dissent

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133395002

Assignment:

Post 1: In his dissenting opinion in Boumediene, Chief Justice Roberts stated that, "One cannot help but think that, after surveying the modest practical results of the majority's ambitious opinion, that this decision is not really about the detainees at all, but about control of federal policy regarding enemy combatants." Why did the Chief Justice state this? Do you agree? What was the primary basis for the Chief Justice's dissent? Include your own analysis from Hamdi. You may also use material from Justice Scalia's dissent to support your answer.

Post 2: Using Justice Jackson's tripartite framework, argue (1) whether Korematsu was correctly decided from a legal/constitutional perspective and (2) whether you agree with the decision from a personal standpoint. Without in any way offering an opinion of my own, I encourage you to try your best to separate your legal analysis from your personal feelings. Include biblical arguments to support your answer.

Reference no: EM133395002

Questions Cloud

Why is it important to health and nursing practice : How are the concepts you learned this week important to health and/or nursing practice? 3. Why is it important to health and nursing practice

How each of the multidisciplinary components of diversity : how each of the multidisciplinary components of diversity (such as culture, ethnicity, race, class, gender, sexual orientation and identity, religion, etc.

How does it positively impact the community : Give an example of a personal experience that you've had with a company that demonstrates a noteworthy level of corporate social responsibility.

What have you learned about yourself and others as a result : Include a self-reflection of your own growth and development - what have you learned about yourself and others as a result of this information

What was the primary basis for the chief justices dissent : Why did the Chief Justice state this? Do you agree? What was the primary basis for the Chief Justice's dissent? Include your own analysis from Hamdi.

Discuss principles of research and evidence-based practice : Discuss the principles of research and evidence-based practice and how to effectively implement them for advanced practice nurses.

Review the ethical perspectives from the canvas supplemental : Review the ethical perspectives from the Canvas supplemental readings and the textbook and give specific examples of companies that have used different approach

How do tactical efforts of population health management : How do tactical efforts of population health management rely on the efforts of community partnerships and social determinants of health?

How many seconds will increases risk for suction-induced : When performing nasopharyngeal suctioning, suction time greater than how many seconds will increases risk for suction-induced hypoxemia

User Account

All Pages