Reference no: EM131230983
PEM, a pharmaceutical company created by the merger of Pfizer—Eli Lily and Merck, sells an over-the-counter cold remedy through its wholly owned subsidiary Mizac LLC. Between 2009 and 2013, PEM received several complaints from physicians and Mizac consumers alleging a connection between the use of Mizac’s leading product, Mizac Cold Remedy, and loss of smell (anosmia). Even after being notified of an American Rhinologic Society presentation that described eleven Mizac users who lost their sense of smell after using the product, PEM made announcements that Mizac was “poised for growth in the upcoming cough and cold season” and that the company expected that revenues would “be up in excess of 50% and that earnings, per share for the full year [would] be in the 25 to 30 cent range.” In an SEC report, Mizac reported the potential “material adverse effect” that could result from consumer complaints of anosmia but did not disclose that two consumers had already sued.
In early 2014, PEM’s stock price fell by about 22% when Dow Jones Newswires reported that, in light of at least three lawsuits, the Food and Drug Administration was investigating complaints that Mizac may have caused some users to lose their sense of smell. PEM revived its stock price with a press release stating that there had been no reports of loss of smell in clinical trials of Mizac and that anosmia can result from the common cold. The stock price fell again when Good Morning America reported that more than a dozen Mizac users had lost their sense of smell. PEM reported to the SEC that, after meeting with “physicians and scientists to review current information on smell disorders,” it concluded that “there is insufficient scientific evidence at this time to determine if Mizac, when used as recommended, affects a person’s ability to smell.” A few weeks later, PEM stated that it would begin “animal and human studies to further characterize these post-marketing complaints.”
Shareholders brought a class action against PEM alleging that it violated SEC Rule 10b-5 and section 10(b) of the 1934 Act when it made misleading statements that failed to disclose reports of the possible link between Mizac and anosmia in an effort to maintain artificially high prices for PEM securities. PEM argued that the adverse event reports were not material information, as no statistically significant relationship was shown between reports of anosmia and use of the Mizac product. Plaintiffs countered that materiality should be determined by the “total mix of information” test.
Did PEM have a legal obligation to disclose information about possible side effects of its drug when there was no statistical information that linked use of the drug with the side effects?
What types of information will the court review to determine whether using the drug causes the side effect?
What standard will the court apply to address evidence of the claim?
Have the plaintiffs stated a valid claim under Rule 10b-5 and section 10(b), or will the court grant PEM’s motion to dismiss?
Did PEM act ethically?
Ebay structures its bid for change
: Read the following case description of "eBay Structures Its Bid for Change". After reading this case, you should prepare your analysis following the guidelines I have provided. The purpose of this assignment is for you to demonstrate that you can app..
|
Importance of establishing ground rules-respecting cultures
: Explain the importance of establishing ground rules and respecting cultures amongst team members. How does diversity within members affect the performances of the group as a whole?
|
Herzbergs two-factor theory
: If you have taken the time to review Herzberg’s work, you may have learned that people accept a job and stay on the job for different motivational reasons. Using at least three comparison web examples from the industry you used in your “Herzberg’s Tw..
|
Research the patient protection and affordable care act
: What are the major issues surrounding access to healthcare in America today? In your view, what might be done to address these issues and improve access? In the U.S., can a low-income person receive access to high-quality care? Research the Patient P..
|
What standard will court apply to address evidence of claim
: PEM, a pharmaceutical company created by the merger of Pfizer—Eli Lily and Merck, sells an over-the-counter cold remedy through its wholly owned subsidiary Mizac LLC. Did PEM have a legal obligation to disclose information about possible side effects..
|
Ethic of care
: Ethic of Care: this ethical perspective denotes that a person or an organiza should care for the concrete well being of those near them. as a manager of a company that makes and sells products, what is your ethics of care perspectives?
|
Elements of managed care pharmacy benefit program
: What are the most important elements of a managed care pharmacy benefit program? And how are patient prescription benefits typically different under managed care? What factors surrounding behavioral health create special challenges and special consid..
|
What is my audiences general attitude toward my subject
: For each communication task below, write brief answers to three questions: (1) Who is my audience? (2) What is my audience's general attitude toward my subject? (3) What does my audience need to know?
|
What is good strategy execution
: What is good strategy execution? Discuss the three components of building an organization capable of proficient strategy execution. What is outsourcing? What are the merits of outsourcing the performance of certain value chainactivities as opposed to..
|