What should be included in user benefits and disbenefits

Reference no: EM131778385

Question: The Victorian government has decided that it is necessary to build a highway connecting Redhill with Dromana on the Mornington Peninsula. Route A follows the existing road and is estimated to cost $28 million initially and $250,000 per year thereafter. A new route, B, will cost $49 million initially (including land acquisition and new culverts, but only $215,000 per year thereafter in maintenance. Route C is simply an enhanced version of route B with wider lanes, shoulders, and so on. It will cost $63 million at first, plus $285,000 per year in maintenance. Relevant annual user costs are estimated to be $12/trip for route A, $7.70 per trip for route B and $6 per trip for route C. Also it is estimated that 585,000 trips will be made along this highway. In accordance with guidelines from Infrastructure Australia, a social discount factor of 7% is required for any planning for new highways.

(a) Discuss what should be included in the user benefits and disbenefits. Comment on whether these have all been allowed for in the data provided.

(b) Determine which route is preferred. Clearly show your calculation method.

Reference no: EM131778385

Questions Cloud

How did bentham include animals in the moral domain : How did Bentham include animals in the moral domain? Why or why not? What was Mill's crisis? How did it affect his subsequent philosophizing?

An ethical analysis based upon the different belief systems : How would each religion interpret the nature of George's malady and suffering? Is there a why to his disease and suffering?

Whats the fast part of the carbon cycle : What effect of the increasing CO2 concentration un the atmosphere on the GPP of an ecosystem?

What is the amount of maintenance : What is the amount of maintenance that would be allocated to the machining department, assuming Hampton uses the step-method to allocate the costs

What should be included in user benefits and disbenefits : The Victorian government has decided that it is necessary to build a highway connecting Redhill with Dromana on the Mornington Peninsula.

Identify global societal issue you have chosen to research : Identify the global societal issue you have chosen to research for your Final Argumentative Essay and explain why further research on this topic is important.

Journalize the transactions for the month of july : Journalize the transactions for the month of July for Ready-Set-Go using a perpetual inventory system - Ready-Set-Go's chart of accounts includes

What factors influence women in civic engagement : What factors influence women in civic engagement? What might some of the barriers or challenges to social entrepreneurship might women face in your city?

How are analytical procedures used in an audit engagement : How are analytical procedures used in an audit engagement? What premise underlies the use of analytical procedures in auditing

User Account

All Pages