What role should science play in our societies

Assignment Help Science
Reference no: EM131393151

Neil deGrasse Tyson, the famous astrophysicist and science communicator (perhaps best known for the 2014 science documentary 'Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey' he presented), has recently suggested on Twitter that "Earth needs a virtual country: #Rationalia, with a one-line Constitution: All policy shall be based on the weight of evidences." The Tyson article is a further elaboration on the idea of Rationalia, and the Guhin piece is a sociologist's response.

This debate brings up some questions relevant to our course: What role should science play in our societies? How do we define science or religion? Does each have their own "legitimate magisterium" that does not (or should not) overlap? If we are worried about preventing religious ideas and beliefs from intervening in scientific activities and public policies, how should we draw boundaries between science and religion?

Imagine yourself writing a short opinion piece for a newspaper about Neil deGrasse Tyson's 'Rationalia' proposal. In your piece, please (1) begin by briefly summarizing what the 'Rationalia' proposal is about, (2) move to a discussion of 2-3 aspects of the 'Rationalia' proposal that you find valuable, interesting, unjustified, or problematic, and (3) end with a brief note on the public debate on science and religion (by using insights from Stephen Jay Gould's article on 'nonoverlapping magisteria').

1) Required readings

* Neil deGrasse Tyson (2016, August 7), "Reflections on Rationalia," Retrieved from

https://www.facebook.com/notes/neil-degrasse-tyson/reflections-on-rationalia/10154399608556613

* Jeffrey Guhin (2016, July 5), "A Nation Ruled by Science Is a Terrible Idea," Retrieved from:

https://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2016/07/neil_degrasse_tyson_wants_a_nation_ruled_by_evidence_but_evidence_explains.html

* Stephen Jay Gould (1997), "Nonoverlapping Magisteria," Natural History 106: 16-22 (reproduced here:

https://www.stephenjaygould.org/library/gould_noma.html)

2) Reflection essay (minimum of 400 words)

Reference no: EM131393151

Questions Cloud

Discuss which predictions you agree or disagree with : Comment on which predictions were correct and which ones were inaccurate. Discuss which predictions you agree or disagree with.
Describe the components necessary to create identity : describe the components necessary to create an effective professional identity and explain why professional networks are essential for professional development.
What are the legal and ethical implications of change : What are the legal and ethical implications of change? How should current employees and leaders begin to prepare for this change? Prepare a change management plan that includes strategies to communicate relevant information to employees.
Describe levels of uncertainty and complexity for project : Describe the levels of uncertainty and complexity for the project. Determine what the project manager should communicate to the customers about the project unknowns.
What role should science play in our societies : Neil deGrasse Tyson, the famous astrophysicist and science communicator (perhaps best known for the 2014 science documentary 'Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey' he presented), has recently suggested on Twitter that "Earth needs a virtual country: #Rati..
Explain the elements of the project plan that depend on wbs : Describe the elements of the project plan that depend on the WBS, and provide examples of any four. Explain why it is useful to have a complete WBS before engaging in formal uncertainty assessment.
Which characteristics are most important : Which characteristics are most important? How are we doing? Can we attain this list?Answer this discussion question: Please make sure it is original with good grammar. Must be at least 200 words, NO cover sheet is needed also single space..
Calculate the current in the capacitor : A coil of inductance 225mH and series resistance 25 Ω is connected in parallel with a 100uF capacitor. If the network is connected across a 250V 50Hz supply, calculate the following: The supply current (magnitude and phase angle) and The current in..
Which study design do you think is the most reliable : Which study design do you think is the most reliable? Why?What about the most comprehensive? Why?Choosing a study design is based on evaluating strengths and weaknesses and comparing it against the type of information you are hoping to gain.Analyze..

Reviews

Write a Review

Science Questions & Answers

  Legal issues in health care

A critical regulatory issue in health care.

  Fir and iir filters in dsp applications

How can the DSP be used in communications systems such as in radio transmitter/receivers?

  Independence using chi-squared distribution

In order to assess rates of faulty installation for home solar panel arrays, a sample of homes with recently installed arrays was examined by expert assessors and each array was graded as either "unsafe", "sub-standard" or "acceptable".

  Why it is important regardless of the method you use

What levels of evidence are present in relation to research and practice, and why it is important regardless of the method you use?

  In 3 pages using apa-style formatting describe and give

in 3 pages using apa-style formatting discuss and give your position on the following statement human activity

  The federal reserve bank act

"The Federal Reserve Bank Act of 1978 requires the Fed to pursue full employment as well as low inflation, but Mr. Greenspan has said that he favors legislation to make price stability the Fed's sole objective." The main reason the chairman of ..

  What do most geologists think causes movement of earth plate

What do most geologists think causes the movement of Earth's plates? What does most geologists think the movement of earth's plates are caused by what? What do geologists think occurs in the mantle of the earth to drive the movements of earths pla..

  Needed for the development of health policy

Which stage of the policy process will be the most difficult for your policy to pass, and why. Differentiate information needed for the development of health policy.

  What are the types of albinism

What are the types of Albinism? What are the difference between the different kinds of Albinism?

  How does the hope of the resurrection play a role

How does the hope of the resurrection play a role in comforting Wolterstorff?

  The triune brain

The Triune Brain: Your Brain The reptilian brain, the oldest of the three, controls the body's vital functions such as heart rate, breathing, body temperature and balance

  Three emerging aspects of the third revolution

Using each of the three emerging aspects of the Third Revolution, describe one alternative global future. You may do this by listing the aspects and offering examples that point to trends. You may also do this by writing a short science fiction piece..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd