What odds of recovery would be good odds

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM131107589

In each case, answer the questions at the end of the case and give researched references to support your assertions; also, explain what would be the ethical course of action and the legal requirements for action in the case.

Case One

Mrs. G. has an aneurysm in her brain that, if untreated by surgery, will lead to blindness and probably death. The surgery recommended leads to death in 75% of all cases. Of those who survive the operation, nearly 75% are crippled. Mrs. G has three small children. Her husband has a modest job, and his health insurance will cover the operation, but not the expenses that will result if she is crippled.

When informed of this, Mrs. G. is in great emotional turmoil for a week or so until she makes her decision. She refuses treatment, because she does not like the odds. There was, after all, only a one chance out of sixteen for a real recovery. In addition, she could not come to grips with exposing her family to the risk of having a mother who would be a burden and not a help.

Can a patient with serious obligations, such as a family, refuse treatment? What odds of recovery would be good odds?

Case Two

Mrs. S., an 85-year-old housewife, becomes aware of breathlessness and is easily fatigued. She is known to have had a heart murmur for 2 years. She consents to come to a research hospital for cardiac catheterization, which confirms the presence of severe, calcific aortic stenosis with secondary congestive heart failure.

Because of the unfavorable prospect for survival without surgical intervention, the recommendation at the combined cardiac medical-surgical conference is for an operation. The physician explains the situation to Mr. and Mrs. S. and recommends aortic valve replacement. It is noted that the risk of surgery is not well known for Mrs. S,'s age group, and that early mortality is usually around 10 percent, with 80 percent achieving good functional results after 3 years. Her lack of an obvious disease makes her a relatively good candidate for a successful surgical outcome, despite her age.

Mrs. S. appears to understand the discussion and recommendation, but requests deferral of the decision and shows signs of denial of the problem. She has no other medical problems, her husband is in good health, and their marriage appears to be happy. They are financially secure and enjoy a full set of social and recreational activities. She returns on three subsequent occasions for simple, supportive attention. The physician decides not to employ psychiatric assistance or other measures to reduce her denial and begins to use conversation to reduce her anxiety associated with her decision.

Does Mrs. S.'s apparent denial of her condition make informed consent impossible? Is the physician ethical in reducing her anxiety about her apparent refusal of treatment when the physician believes treatment is medically indicated?

Reference no: EM131107589

Questions Cloud

Calculate the contribution margin per unit : Sokolov Company sells a product for $12. Unit costs are as follows: Direct materials $1.90
Negative for the sale of certain number of units : If the marginal profit is negative for the sale of a certain number of units of a product, is the company that is marketing the item losing money on the sale? Explain. If the marginal profit is negative for the sale of a certain number of units,
Shares of mno common stock : A person owned 300 shares of MNO common stock, which cost $23,400. MNO then had a 3-for-1 stock split. After the split, the person sold 100 shares for $5,600. How much gain (or loss) resulted from the sale?
Increase the loans account and the account : This would increase the loans account and the account. This would also bring the leverage ratio from its initial value of to a new value of . Which of the following is true of the capital requirement?
What odds of recovery would be good odds : Does Mrs. S.'s apparent denial of her condition make informed consent impossible? Is the physician ethical in reducing her anxiety about her apparent refusal of treatment when the physician believes treatment is medically indicated?
Planning for the next tax preparation season : An accounting firm is planning for the next tax preparation season. From last year's returns, the firm collects a systematic random sample of 100 filings. The 100 filings showed an average preparation time of 90 minutes with a standard deviation o..
Prepare a bank reconciliation for oldroyd company : 2. The canceled checks returned by the bank included a check written by the Oldham Company for $1,764 that had been deducted from Oldroyd s account in error.
Effects on the savings inter-temporal budget constranit : Graph the effects on the savings inter-temporal budget constranit. You are required to use the graphical representation of the llifecycle model's inter-temporal budget constraint. Assume a progressive tax system with 2 tax brackets are applicable for..
Major competitors of nikon : Who are the major competitors of Nikon and what does this corporation do to deal with these Two Competitors?

Reviews

Write a Review

HR Management Questions & Answers

  Improve problem solving capabilities within organization

Types of teams as to their effectiveness that will improve problem solving capabilities within organizations.

  Influence tactics help in reducing organizations politics

Explain the different types of influence tactics that will be of a help “if adopted” in reducing the organizational politics.

  Report on citigroup''s hr service level agreement

Human Resources or Human Resource Management deals with HR Service Level Agreement. HR Service Level Agreement is an agreement made between the employer and the employee, which states that the employee would work under any client and sometimes any ti..

  A project report on hrm

Human Resource Management as the name suggests, it is a management discipline which deals with the human i.e. the workforce aspect of organizations. Need and practices of HRM are inevitable in present scenario of extreme competition where "Talent War..

  Hrp: recruitment and selection

Recruitment and Selection is the initial ladder of any Human Resource Planning process and contains an immense significance for any organisation.

  A project report on study of statutory complainces

Statutory compliance and its immense knowledge are crucial to be understood in an organization. It contains all the forms, procedures and acts applicable in a company.

  Operant conditioning and Reinforcement

Operant conditioning is a learning process where behaviour is controlled by its consequences. In this process an individual's behaviour can be modified through the use of positive or negative reinforcement.

  Effectiveness of training programs in achieving customers an

The main motive for conducting this research is to provide broad range of research of the literature and their reviews related to training and development and assisting the employees in providing customers satisfaction.

  A critical analysis of hr processes and practices in fedex c

FedEx is illustrious for its novel HR processes and practices that have greatly accounted for its success.

  Integrating culture and diversity in decision making

People in the organization are known as Google where they share common goals and have common vision.

  Impact of employee attrition on people management in organis

Talent management implies recognizing a person's inherent skills, traits, personality and offering him a matching job.

  Labour dissonance at maruti suzuki india limited: a case stu

This Case Study focuses on various issues related to Labour Unrest at Maruti Suzuki India Limited.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd