What issues do the rulings have on rights of the individual

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133515217

Assignment

Case: Illinois v. Gates

Editor's Note: With so many cases affecting policing, the question often arises regarding which are the most important. If a law enforcement professional could choose only 10 cases to examine, which would those be? Included in this series is a list of what experts Rolando del Carmen and Jeffery Walker consider to be the top 10 cases most influencing day-to-day policing in the U.S. Continuing from our last installment, in reverse order, we give you number 9: Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213 (1983).

Capsule

The two-pronged test for probable cause established in previous cases is superseded in favor of the "totality of circumstances" test.

Facts

On May 3, 1978, the Bloomingdale, Illinois, police department received an anonymous letter containing the following statements: that Gates and his wife were engaged in selling drugs, that the wife would drive her car to Florida on May 3 to be loaded with drugs, that Gates would fly to Florida and drive the car back to Illinois, that the trunk would be loaded with drugs, and that Gates had more than $100,000 worth of drugs in his basement. Acting on the tip, a police officer obtained Gates' address and learned that he had made reservations for a May 5 flight to Florida. Arrangements for surveillance of the flight were made with an agent of the Drug Enforcement Administration. The surveillance disclosed that Gates took the flight, stayed overnight in a hotel room registered in his wife's name, and left the following morning with a woman in a car bearing an Illinois license plate, heading north. A search warrant for Gates' house and automobile was obtained on the basis of the officer's affidavit setting forth the foregoing facts and a copy of the anonymous letter. When Gates arrived at his home, the police were waiting. A search of the house and car revealed marijuana and other contraband. Gates was charged with violating state drug laws and was convicted.

Issue

Did the affidavit and the anonymous letter provide sufficient facts to establish probable cause for the issuance of a warrant? YES.

Supreme Court Decision

The two-pronged test established under Aguilar and Spinelli is superseded in favor of a "totality of circumstances" approach. The task of an issuing magistrate is to make a practical decision whether, given all the circumstances, there is a fair probability that the evidence of a crime will be found in a particular place.

Reason

"Unlike a totality of circumstances analysis, which permits a balanced assessment of the relative weights of all the various indicia of reliability (and unreliability) attending an informant's tip, the ‘two-pronged test' has encouraged an excessively technical dissection of informants' tips, with undue attention being focused on isolated issues that cannot sensibly be divorced from the other facts presented to the magistrate."

Case Significance

The two-pronged test for establishing probable cause in cases in which information is given by an informant is modified and superseded by the "totality of circumstances" test, making it easier for police officers to establish probable cause for the issuance of a warrant. Under the two-pronged test as enunciated in Aguilar v. Texas, 378 U.S. 108 (1964), probable cause based on information obtained from an informant could be established only if the following were present: (1) reliability of the informant and (2) reliability of the informant's information. Both conditions must have been satisfied before probable cause could be established. In contrast, under the "totality of circumstances" test, probable cause may be established if, based on all the circumstances (including hearsay), there is a fair probability that contraband or evidence of crime will be found in a particular place. The Gates case still preserves the two-pronged test established in Aguilar, but it does not treat the two aspects separately and independently. Instead, the "totality of circumstances" approach is used, meaning that whatever deficiencies there may be in one prong can be supplemented or overcome by the other, together with other available evidence.

For many more cases, see Briefs of Leading Cases in Law Enforcement, 8th ed., which includes short, easy-to-understand briefs of 185 cases of primary importance to law enforcement officials.

Task

Discuss the ramifications of the multidimensional police bottom line. If you were a mayor, how would use this bottom line to determine how good your town's police department was and what it should do to improve? Police in a democracy (no more than 100 words)

The police system in the United States is very proactive and emphasized crime-fighting be like? What are some pros and cons to this approach to policing? Police in a democracy(no more than100 words)

Provide a case review / discussion response for each case, with due dates assigned as per the syllabus:

No more than a page but should include the following:

A. What is the primary issue of the case (amendment, practice, etc.)

B. Your opinions - substantiated with elements from class and/or your understanding of the Criminal Justice System

C. What issues do the rulings have on rights of the individual while at the same time discuss the impact to Law Enforcement. Discuss the Pros and Cons as appropriate

D. Provide a conclusion if appropriate.

Reference no: EM133515217

Questions Cloud

What might you have done if you were dr martinson : After reading the case study, what are your thoughts concerning Dr. Martinson's course of action? What might you have done if you were Dr. Martinson.

Describe ecological footprint : Please consider and use your ecological footprint result and discuss the how this relates to a quality of life indicators in least-developed countries.

How would the legal dilemma posed in the scenario : How would the legal dilemma posed in this scenario likely be resolved if no Constitution existed? Does what you imagine seem impartial and fair to all parties?

What does it mean to decolonize language : explain the main idea and what you have learned. What does it mean to decolonize language? Refer to the episodes you listened to, to help explain.

What issues do the rulings have on rights of the individual : What issues do the rulings have on rights of the individual while at the same time discuss the impact to Law Enforcement.

How can you connect the four core goals of anti-bias : How can you connect the four core goals of anti-bias education to data collection and assessment within the early childhood environment?

Describing how the families and child learning and routine : Describing how the families and child's learning and routine needs are meet during enrolment and orientation process.

Which character do you feel is the important in the story : Although all the actions occurs between Newt and Catherine, there are actually four different characters. Which character do you feel is the important

What is the potential energy of the crate after it is lifted : What is the potential energy of the crate after it is lifted? If it takes 10 seconds to lift the cheese, what is the power rating of the lifting device?

User Account

All Pages