User Account

All Pages

What is the overarching conclusion of the piece

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131288625 , Length: word count:1000

In this assignment, you will be utilizing all of the various tools, knowledge and techniques you have been acquiring in this course. You will be preparing a critical essay (ca. 800-1000 words) examining an argumentative essay.

On pp. 209-210, Bassham discusses the nature and content of a critical essay. Please look at this bit of text very carefully. Then, on pp. 219-224, Bassham provides an example of a (much less than stellar) argumentative essay "In Defense of Cheating" and a sample critical essay evaluating it.

In this sample critical essay, Bassham is not seeking (and certainly not achieving!) elegance. Rather, he is deliberately displaying the structure of such an essay, showing its "skeleton" so to speak. I would like you to do the same in your essay. You are to show me you understand what such an essay IS and how it's constructed, and demonstrate your skill in analyzing an argumentative essay utilizing the various tools we have been sharpening in the preceding units.

To be sure: instead of utilizing Bassham's argument-standardization technique, I would like you to lay out (your reading of) the line of argument in "Enhanced Standard Form" as explained in the Guides to Units 5 and 6 and the tutorials for Unit 5.

The piece you will be examining is "Serving the Nation: A Universal Call" (attached here.)

Consideration of some of the following questions may help in in preparing your critique:

1. What is the overarching conclusion of (the argument of) the piece?

2. What are the different main arguments (and SORTS of arguments) the author makes for his conclusion? Can you find (or generate) a (few) general claims/headings under which you can organize most of the arguments/premises/evidence? Do these arguments support the conclusion dependently or independently?

3. Do you understand the information in the first paragraph to be a component of the line of argument, or merely background information? If the former, what sort of argument is it? Do you find anything fallacious here? If, however, it is a legitimate (part of the) argument: why so?

4. What, EXACTLY, do the arguments really count for: military TRAINING, military SERVICE, or both (or neither), or something else again (e.g. mandatory Civil Defense training/duty?) (Do you find any important differences between these things?)

5. The main (part of the) line of argument (4th paragraph) is intended as PROBLEM-SOLVING. What problems - exactly - are being addressed? Are they clearly defined in enough specificity? Are the problems real, serious and correctly identified? Would the proposed solution actually (help to) solve the problems? Why or why not? Might there be better (i.e. cheaper, more efficient, more focused, less intrusive) means to achieve the same ends?

6. For those parts of the arguments not directly addressing the problem-solving aspect: do they contribute to supporting/legitimizing the proposed conclusion? If so, in what ways?

7. Are there any rebuttal premises/arguments in the piece? If so, what are the (possible) objection(s) being rebutted? Do you think the piece succeeds in achieving this? What OTHER possible objections might be made? (A hint: WHY do you think the author includes the "patriotic obligation" point? Might it be intended to rebut some [unidentified] objection?)

Your ESF-outline will help you in answering these questions, but - in turn - answering some of these questions should also help you fine-tune your outline. So feel free to edit/revise/refine your outline as you go.

I suggest that you number the paragraphs in the "Serving' piece for easy reference in your essay.

Link to textbook if necessary

https://s3.amazonaws.com/engrade-myfiles/4008228113384505/Students_Guide_to_Critical_Thinking.pdf

Reference no: EM131288625

Questions Cloud

Average variable costs exceed the price : What will a competitive firm do in the short term if the average variable costs exceed the price?
What is demography and why is it so important for marketers : Name and briefly describe the elements of an organization's microenvironment and discuss how they affect marketing.
Explain a description of health care workforce shortage : Explain a description of the health care workforce shortage and its implications. The aspects that need immediate attention and aspects that need long term attention. Provide a rationale on why these aspects need attention.
Respond to multinational competitors : What factors predict how local emerging firms will respond to multinational competitors?
What is the overarching conclusion of the piece : What are the different main arguments (and SORTS of arguments) the author makes for his conclusion? Can you find (or generate) a (few) general claims/headings under which you can organize most of the arguments/premises/evidence? Do these arguments..
Discuss trends in the natural environment : Discuss trends in the natural environment of which marketers must be aware, and provide examples of companies' responses to them.
About the uses of managerial accounting : Which statement is false about the uses of managerial accounting? 1 Managerial accounting cannot be used to determine how many products need to be sold in order to cover recurring cost 2 Managerial accounting is used to support long-term planning dec..
Estate did not elect the alternate valuation date : In 1997, Ward and June, husband and wife, bought 160 acres of land as Joint Tenants With Right of Survivorship, for $200,000. Ward died in the current year. On the date of his death, the land was worth $300,000. The personal representative of Ward's ..
Write a message to scott that informs him of shipment delay : Write a message to Scott that informs him of the shipment delay. The message should explain that Lucia thinks that Scott should hold off on the corporate job and start the Herbert Street job instead.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Define each of five personality characteristics in big five

From the first e-Activity, describe Huston's four major findings from the "PAIR (Process of Adaptation in Intimate Relationships) Project". Evaluate the accuracy of the findings by comparing them with your own experiences (either in your own marri..

  Ensemble do to do stay together if there is no conductor

With an orchestra, a string quartet, and a drum and bugle corps, what is the differences in the sound/timbre and instrumentation of each? Which of the three have conductors and how involved is the conductor in controlling the ensemble? What kinds of ..

  Conduct an internal analysis of the company

Drawing on relevant analytical models and researched data, carry out an analysis of the industry or sector within which the company operates. The directors are particularly keen to know how their industry is affected by global forces and innovatio..

  List of factors a mental health professional

list of factors a mental health professional would need to consider when determining a juvenile’s amenability. Make sure you include factors that would support amenability to treatment as well as factors that would work against amenability to treatme..

  Describe some of guidelines that you are required to follow

Many of you are already working in various roles in various healthcare environments. Describe some of the guidelines and protocols that you are required to follow when it comes to protecting patient information.

  Who would have final say in terms of ethical decision-making

If you were the patient, who would have the final say in terms of ethical decision-making and intervention in the event of a difficult situation?

  Singapore and china-finance and organization

Illustrate the difference between Singapore and China in terms of their finance and organization?

  Assumption that the state should regulate economic policy

Keynesian economists begin with the assumption that the state should regulate economic policy for everyone's benefit. Why might sociologists who use market-oriented theories be critical of this idea?

  Report on paul mccartney and ludwig van beethoven

In brainstorming the compositional characteristics of these two composers and their music from totally different time periods. This will be need to address the following characteristics:

  Explain what are some examples to reinforce response

What stereotypes did you find represented your own views in reading Powell. How do these stereotypes influence your perception of diversity

  Assignment innovation and sustainability

Assignment Innovation and Sustainability

  Which work or works effectively express this theme

Do you think the poem, short story, and play effectively convey the authors' intent? Explain. What common theme can you find linking the poem, short story, and play?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

Submit Assignment

Academics

Major Subjects

Majors

Get In Touch

whatsapp: +1-415-670-9521

Phone: +1-415-670-9521

Email: [email protected]

TERMS & POLICIES

HELP & SUPPORT

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd