What is the explanatory variable in given study

Reference no: EM131405800

Refer to given Exercise, in which one or more third variables are at least partially likely to account for the observed relationship between religious activities and reduced incidence of high blood pressure. Is this an example of Simpson's paradox? Explain.

Exercise
Case Study was called "Does Prayer Lower Blood Pressure?" One of the results quoted in that study was, "People who attended a religious service once a week and prayed or studied the Bible once a day were 40% less likely to have high blood pressure than those who don't go to church every week and prayed and studied the Bible less."

a. What is the explanatory variable in this study?

b. What is the response variable in this study?

c. Give an example of a third variable that might at least partially account for the observed relationship.

Case Study
Does Prayer Lower Blood Pressure?
Read the original source on the companion website, https:// www.cengage.com/statistics/Utts4e.

News headlines are notorious for making one of the most common mistakes in the interpretation of statistical studies: jumping to unwarranted conclusions. A headline in USA Today read, "Prayer can lower blood pressure" (Davis, 1998). The story that followed continued the possible fallacy it began by stating, "Attending religious services lowers blood pressure more than tuning into religious TV or radio, a new study says." The words "attending religious services lowers blood pressure" imply a direct cause-and-effect relationship. This is a strong statement, but it is not justified by the research project described in the article.

The article was based on an observational study conducted by the U.S. National Institutes of Health, which followed 2391 people aged 65 or older for 6 years. The article described one of the study's principal findings: "People who attended a religious service once a week and prayed or studied the Bible once a day were 40% less likely to have high blood pressure than those who don't go to church every week and prayed and studied the Bible less" (Davis, 1998). So the researchers did observe a relationship, but it's a mistake to think that this justifies the conclusion that prayer actually causes lower blood pressure. When groups are compared in an observational study, the groups usually differ in many important ways that may contribute to the observed relationship.

In this example, people who attended church and prayed regularly may have been less likely than the others to smoke or to drink alcohol. These could affect the results because smoking and alcohol use are both believed to affect blood pressure. The regular church attendees may have had a better social network, a factor that could lead to reduced stress, which in turn could reduce blood pressure. People who were generally somewhat ill may not have been as willing or able to go out to church. We're sure you can think of other possibilities for confounding variables that may have contributed to the observed relationship between prayer and lower blood pressure.

Moral of the Story: Cause-and-effect conclusions cannot generally be made on the basis of an observational study.

Definitions: An observational study is one in which participants are merely observed and measured. Comparisons based on observational studies are comparisons of naturally occurring groups. A variable is a characteristic that differs from one individual to the next. It may be numerical, such as blood pressure, or it may be categorical, such as whether or not someone attends church regularly. A confounding variable is a variable that is not the main concern of the study but may be partially responsible for the observed results.

Reference no: EM131405800

Questions Cloud

What are some of the key positive aspects of the team : What are some of the key positive aspects of this team? Discuss some specific positives and include some stories of times when the team functioned especially well.

Discuss current pre-existing knowledge on determining labor : Discuss current PRE-EXISTING KNOWLEDGE on determining labor and material costs (use the textbook, lecture and internet searches) and explain how these methods could be applied to the Matador problem.

What idea in the assigned readings do you find most useful : What concept/idea in the assigned readings do you find most intriguing or useful? Why? How might you or others apply it? (theassigned reading "From Horseless to Driverless" is ONLY for Question 2)

Write about provider of security or privacy products : Your assignment this week is to gather information on a provider of security/privacy products and write a short recommendation document

What is the explanatory variable in given study : What is the explanatory variable in this study?- What is the response variable in this study?- Give an example of a third variable that might at least partially account for the observed relationship.

Calculate the tax rates for each income bracket in each year : The "tax rate" for any income category is calculated as tax divided by income. Calculate the tax rates for each income bracket in each year.

Develop a knowledge base that is integrated with other : The professional logistics manager must develop a knowledge base that is integrated with other disciplines. Based on what you read in the module and review of the supplemental readings, please take a proponent stance on either the traditional inve..

Evaluate the fundamental driving forces : Evaluate the fundamental driving forces that shape the organizational environment of the selected company. Be sure to address the following: competing in a global marketplace, workforce diversity, ethics and morality, and technological innovation.

Evaluation of a potential client web site : You have recently gained employment with a computer consultancy company. Due to your specialist knowledge in the areas of Human Factors and usability, your manager considers that you are ideal to undertake an evaluation of a potential client's web..

User Account

All Pages