What is the claim brutus is making here

Assignment Help History

Reference no: EM133316601

Assignment:

Answer the following questions about Brutus No. 15:

What is the author's purpose in writing this essay?
How did lifetime tenure for British judges help secure the rights of the people against the monarch?
Explain why the British system of government differs from conditions in America.
What is the claim Brutus is making here?
What evidence does Brutus use to support the claim that the judiciary is superior to the other branches? (You may need to read the text on the next page to fully answer this question.)
What is the provision Brutus cites as the only way to remove judges?
What are the limitations of that provision?
How is Brutus defining the power of judicial review?
How is he supporting the claim that the power of judicial review places the judiciary above the legislature?
How, according to Brutus, can the design of the judiciary threaten state governments?
State the remedy the people have if the legislature was given the power to interpret the Constitution and "exceeded their powers" in doing so.
Why, according to Brutus, would this "remedy" not apply to the Supreme Court as outlined in the Constitution?
Based on his argument, explain how Brutus' view differs from Hamilton's on lifetime tenure for judges.
Discuss some of the implications of one of these differences.
How does this essay contribute to earlier Anti-Federalist arguments that the real purpose of the new Constitution was to consolidate the nation under one government by, over time, eliminating the power of the states?
Based on the evidence, who do you think makes the more compelling argument, Brutus or Hamilton? Specifically, does the Supreme Court have too much power or is it the "least dangerous" branch of our federal government? Support your response with examples.
Some have argued that the Supreme Court, being unelected, has too much power in our system to "make new policy" through its decisions. While others believe that the Court has been an important check on both legislative and executive power. What do you think? Support your response with examples.

Reference no: EM133316601

Questions Cloud

Contrast the virginia and new jersey plans : Compare and contrast the Virginia and New Jersey plans. Explain how these led to the Great Compromise.

What are risks of having patients and therapists interact : What are the guidelines for a therapist to put personal details about himself/herself on a blog or website or on Facebook or other social networks?

List areas that require further profession development : List 25 specific Skill Sets / Behaviours / Strengths you possess and prove or give evidence that you can demonstrate these, skills. List 4 areas (Skill Sets)

Describing the challenges and opportunities of ai : Read several articles describing the challenges and opportunities of AI. Discuss some of the specific challenges and opportunities for AI within the industry

What is the claim brutus is making here : Explain why the British system of government differs from conditions in America. What is the claim Brutus is making here?

What is the achieving a better life experience act : Identify 2 barriers to employment that people with developmental disabilities may encounter? What is the Achieving a Better Life Experience Act?

Compose an introduction and investigative report : Compose an introduction and Investigative Report/Analyze the problem and pose solutions - NHR works to promote the safe and effective use of drugs

Briefly describe the sector and explain it to the class : Briefly describe the sector and explain it to the class. Why would people be attracted to work in this sector? Is there any reason people should avoid working

Calculate the needed campaign budget : Market testing has shown that the expected CTR is 20% and the engagement rate is 5%. If the CPM for your display ad is $2.50, calculate the needed campaign

User Account

All Pages