What is the causal claim the dentist ad is making

Reference no: EM133703317

Assignment:

Let's imagine there was a researcher who thought that daily flossing could help people live longer. She conducted a panel survey (panel survey just means the survey was conducted with the same people over many years) over 25 years of 100,000 people (let's assume the data collection was done rigorously and carefully). She recruited people at dentist offices. She found that people who flossed daily lived on average 6 years longer than people who didn't floss.

Dental companies like Delta Dental started hyping these findings in the following way:

1. The researcher found that "people who flossed daily lived on average 6 years longer than people who didn't floss." Is that a causal statement, or a statement about a correlation?

2. What is the causal claim the dentist ad is making?

3. What do you think is the dental company's theory for why flossing leads to living longer?

4. What is the independent variable?

5. What is the dependent variable?

6. What might be a confounding variable to this study? (Remember, a confounding variable is something that is affecting both the independent variable and the dependent variable, and leading to a spurious conclusion.)

7. Is reverse causality a concern for this study? If so, in what way?

8. Is selection bias a concern for this study? If so, in what way?

Optional questions:

9. The study described above is an observational study. Remember, that means the researcher is simply observing the world, and observing people who behave differently.

An experimental study would allow us to make stronger causal claims. What would be some of the ethical considerations for an experimental study?

10. Let's imagine you decided the ethical considerations were outweighed by the value to knowledge. How would you design an experiment to test whether flossing caused longevity?

Reference no: EM133703317

Questions Cloud

What is international law : In your own concept, what is international law and why is it important? Explain the kinds of international law and its difference.

How does it benefit the criminal justice system : Summarize the importance of a campus police officer. What are your thoughts on this training? How does it benefit the criminal justice system?

Describe one interagency : Discuss key considerations for interagency cooperation that influences the CCDR and JTF Commanders in the development/ execution of operations.

Establishes impeachment process as a check on presidency : However, some have argued that this mechanism has been used for political or partisan reasons rather than an actual check on the executive.

What is the causal claim the dentist ad is making : What is the causal claim the dentist ad is making? What do you think is the dental company's theory for why flossing leads to living longer?

What was the critical issue leading to each realignment : List and describe the six conditions necessary for a party realignment to occur. What are the realignments that have occurred in our party system?

How is linked to global warming-specifically human security : With examples, discuss the impacts of Global Warming with special reference to human security. Give recommendations or solutions to the problem.

What made new intellectual philosophies modern : How did intellectual developments reflect the ambiguities of modernity? AND What made new intellectual philosophies "modern"?

Describe the impact of wwii on life in detroit : Finally, what were two "errors," according to Martelle, that took place post WWII that set up the city for catastrophe in subsequent decades?

User Account

All Pages