What impact will the court decision most likely have on

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133451292

Case Study: Espresso Disposition Corp. 1 and Santana Sales & Marketing Group, Inc., entered into an agreement that included a mandatory forum selection clause. The clause stated that "the venue with respect to any action pertaining to this Agreement shall be the State of Illinois." When Santana filed a suit against Espresso in a Florida state court, the defendant filed a motion to dismiss based on the clause. Santana responded that the clause was a mistake made at the time the agreement was drafted-an agreement between different parties had been copied, and by mistake, the venue provision had not been changed from Illinois to Florida. The court denied Espresso's motion to dismiss. Espresso appealed.

A state intermediate appellate court reversed and remanded for the entry of an order of dismissal. Under Florida law, a forum selection clause is only considered unjust or unreasonable if a party establishes that enforcement would result in "no forum at all." Espresso failed to establish this "since the designated forum-Illinois-does not result in *??*??* 'no forum at all.'?" If a forum selection clause unambiguously mandates that litigation be subject to a certain forum, then it is wrong for a court to ignore the clause.

Questions

What impact will the court's decision most likely have on the parties to this dispute?
How could the parties, particularly the defendant, have avoided this dispute?
Did the court grant or deny the appellants' motion? Why?

Reference no: EM133451292

Questions Cloud

What are some of legal ramifications the group might face : What are some of the legal ramifications the group might face if one of the group's members pretended that a Canadian celebrity has endorsed their cookies?

Which upholds and enforces a variety of business safeguards : The federal trade commission administrators the bureau of consumer protection, which upholds and enforces a variety of business safeguards for both individuals

Discuss the best strategy for lean implementation : Discuss the best strategy for Lean implementation in the hospitality business

Analyse considering two ethical theories and make : What should the hospital do? Analyse considering two ethical theories and make a conclusion and recommendation?

What impact will the court decision most likely have on : What impact will the court's decision most likely have on the parties to this dispute? How could the parties, particularly the defendant, have avoided this

What does the commercial activity exception to the doctrine : What does the commercial activity exception to the doctrine of sovereign immunity provide? Did Nigeria act ethically in trying to avoid the contract obligations

What is the alberta queen printer : What is the Alberta Queen's Printer? How is the ruling government in Alberta elected? Who is the Minister of Municipal Affairs? Describe his or her biography.

What is the role of parliament : What is the role of Parliament? What are the two "houses" of Parliament? What is the name of the political representatives sitting in Parliament to make laws?

Discuss the concept of the dual mandate : Discuss the concept of the dual mandate. Is the dual mandate an appropriate regulatory tool to support the growth of an industry? Explain and defend

User Account

All Pages