What form of ethical reasoning did autry seem to employ

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM131915238

Question: Deontology

Formalism The German philosopher Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) developed perhaps the most persuasive and fully articulated vision of ethics as measured not by consequences (teleology) but by the rightness of rules. In this formalistic view of ethics, the rightness of an act depends little (or, in Kant's view, not at all) on the results of the act. Kant believed in the key moral concept of "the goodwill." The moral person is a person of goodwill, and that person renders ethical decisions based on what is right, regardless of the consequences of the decision. Moral worth springs from one's decision to discharge one's duty. Thus the student who refuses to cheat on exams is morally worthy if his or her decision springs from duty, but morally unworthy if the decision is merely one born of self-interest, such as fear of being caught.

How does the person of goodwill know what is right? Here Kant propounded the categorical imperative, the notion that every person should act on only those principles that he or she, as a rational person, would prescribe as universal laws to be applied to the whole of humankind. A moral rule is "categorical" rather than "hypothetical" in that its prescriptive force is independent of its consequences. The rule guides us independent of the ends we seek. Kant believed that every rational creature can act according to his or her categorical imperative because all such persons have "autonomous, self-legislating wills" that permit them to formulate and act on their own systems of rules. To Kant, what is right for one is right for all, and each of us can discover that "right" by exercising our rational faculties.

Questions

1. Fifty-year-old Wesley Autry, waiting with his two young daughters in January 2007 at a New York City subway station, saw a man collapse and fall off the passenger platform into the space between the train rails. The headlight of a train appeared. Mr. Autry immediately jumped on top of the fallen man holding him down while the train passed over them, inches above Autry's head. Asked later why he jumped to the rescue, Autry said: "I did what I felt was right."38 What form of ethical reasoning did Autry seem to employ in making his courageous decision?

2. British priest Tim Jones caused a big stir by telling his congregation in 2009 that shoplifting is sometimes morally permissible for desperate people. In a sermon, Jones said that shoplifting can be justified when a person is in real need, is not greedy and takes only what is necessary to get by. Later Jones said: "The point I'm making is that when we shut down every socially acceptable avenue for people in need, then the only avenue left is the socially unacceptable one."39

a. Was Jones arguing from a teleological/consequentialist or a deontological/formalist point of view? Explain.

b. Do you agree with Jones? Explain.

3. In March 2013 as Tiger Woods's golf game was recovering from a long period of poor performance (by his standards), Nike released an ad with Woods's picture and the caption "Winning Takes Care of Everything," a remark Woods reportedly made many times in reference to his golfing performance. Critics attacked Woods and Nike saying the ad implied that golf victories would cancel out the shortcomings and misconduct of Woods's past, including his failed marriage, repeated infidelities and generally perceived arrogant, rude behavior.

a. Is the ad an example of consequentialist or formalist thinking? Explain.

b. In assessing the moral quality of an individual's life, can we properly weigh exemplary productivity against extensive wrongdoing? Consider cyclist Lance Armstrong, who has acknowledged having cheated by engaging in forbidden doping measures. Can we, nonetheless, consider Armstrong a "good person" in light of the enormous contribution he has made as an advocate for cancer research and as an inspiration to those who suffer from cancer? Explain.

c. In your view, was Nike wrong to run the "Winning Takes Care of Everything" ad? Explain.

Reference no: EM131915238

Questions Cloud

Long-term government bonds are normally distributed : Suppose the returns on long-term government bonds are normally distributed. What range would you expect to see 99 percent of the time?
What are the primary functions of the respiratory system : What are the primary functions of the respiratory system? Explain the roles of mucus and cilia in the respiratory system.
Prepare journal entries for the given transactions : Assuming that the James Company uses a perpetual inventory system, prepare journal entries for the above transactions
What is the gain or loss in the futures market : Did the basis strengthen or weaken? Explain. What is the gain or loss in the futures market? Show your work.
What form of ethical reasoning did autry seem to employ : Fifty-year-old Wesley Autry, waiting with his two young daughters in January 2007 at a New York City subway station, saw a man collapse and fall off the passeng
Two stocks to be correctly priced relative to each other : What would the risk-free rate have to be for the two stocks to be correctly priced relative to each other?
What is the annual operating cash flow-ocf-from project : Calculate the project's internal rate of return. What is the annual operating cash flow, OCF, from this project?
Discuss the century-old policy : Toyota has tried to continue its half-century-old policy of not laying off permanent employees. When Toyota halted production in some of its U.S. plants.
Give a general explanation of why the p or e changed : Compute earnings per share and the P/E ratio for 2013.Compute earnings per share and the P/E ratio for 2014.

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  A major chemical company

Upon graduation from college, Edison was hired by a major chemical company. During the time when he was employed by the company, Edison discovered a synthetic oil that could be manufactured at a very low cost.

  Does bribe giving affect the free market system

What is the difference between a bribe and a facilitation fee ? Does it make a difference if payments or bribes are a crime in a foreign country.

  Advise hatfield ofhis rights

The only reference in the agreement to the equipment stated that it was to be a "new model XVX self-propelled combine -Advise Hatfield ofhis rights. Discuss the defences available to Hatfield's claim(s).

  Explain what tools you would use to recover the evidence

Explain how you would recover dried blood, a handgun, shell casings, and hairs that are at the crime scene. What tools you would use to recover the evidence? How would you package the evidence for safekeeping and transportation

  The courts have very broad powers to enforce or not enforce

1 which of the following is not true?a. a minor can still disaffirm a contract for a reasonable time after reaching

  Explain why the duties were breached

Question: Duties/responsibilities breached (ex. CA sections 181 or 588G) and explain why the duties were breached

  Personal property permanently attached to land

Personal property permanently attached to land is known as a: a. quitclaimb. premium

  What is the market user cost of owner-occupied housing

You are looking at a new home in suburban New Jersey which is selling for $250,000. The rent on similar homes in the same development is $1,500 per month. Based on this information, what is the market user cost of owner-occupied housing?

  What was most important in regards to the law enforcement

what was the most important in regards to the law enforcement executive? Be sure to address the legal, administrative and operational perspectives in your response.

  Provide your opinion of whether or not criminal liability

provide your opinion of whether or not criminal liability and punishment for inchoate offenses are fair or not. how do

  Many people believe that the american ideals and values of

many people believe that the american ideals and values of equality and democracy give the united states a kind of

  May racially derogatory statements be made criminal

1. May racially derogatory statements be made criminal? May racial motives be used to enhance the punishment for crimes such as assault and battery?2. May religious beliefs be regulated by the state? May religious practices be regulated by the state?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd