What facts suggest kai is really an employee

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM133194408 , Length: 2 pages

Case 1:

Assume the date is April 2022. Thanks to a new vaccination the covid-19 virus is much less of a problem, and life is mostly back to "normal," but the virus has mutated and people are still being infected and a number of people--including peope in their 20s and 30s-are still dying. People still can't tell if they are infected and contagious.

Kelsey owns a Perfect Pizza franchise on North Lombard St. which has take-out pizza as well as eat-in tables. Like a lot of fast-food outlets, Perfect Pizza has fast turnover of its employees and is constantly hiring new workers. Concerned about the health of her staff and customers Kelsey requires all her employees to get a shot for the new vaccine.

Various employers require their employees to be up-to-date with various medical vaccinations. Oregon law provides that an individual may get an "exemption" from being required to take a medical vaccination if there is a valid medical reason or for 'sincere religious or philosophical objections to vaccination." The exemption application must be signed by a doctor.

Kelsey advertises for an employee and interviews Kai who has a year's experience working at a similar local pizza shop in Seattle before he and his girlfriend moved to Portland. Kelsey tells Kai: You look like a perfect fit--you're hired starting today. I'll set you up on our payroll system for $15/hr. and you can earn overtime if you want it. You can get right to work as soon as you bring me proof of your covid-19 vaccination." Kai signed a contract that described him as an "independent contractor" before he left the restaurant.

The next day Kai appears with a signed "exemption certificate" signed by his doctor. Kelsey responds: "Sorry, but I don't make exceptions on this--no vaccination, no job." The next day Kelsey gets a letter by FedEx delivery from a lawyer telling her: "Kai, my client, objects to his wrongful firing. Under Oregon law, an Oregon employer cannot refuse to recognize a valid medical exemption, including the right to be exempt from vaccinations due to sincere religious beliefs. Kai will report for work on Monday morning. Otherwise we will sue for wrongful discharge." [You may assume that the lawyer is correct-no need to look up Oregon law].

When a Perfect Pizza regional manager drops by the restaurant, he informs Kelsey that as a franchisee their contract requires Kelsey to have all employees near food or customers to wear masks until September 1.

Required: Answer the following, giving reasons for your conclusions

Question 1. What facts suggest Kai is really an employee not an independent contractor? and how does this affect Kai's legal rights here?
Question 2. If Kai is found to be an "at will" employee, can he be fired or let go for any reason? How about this reason, and the fact that Kai is protected by an Oregon statute?
Question 3. Can Kelsey be forced to let Kai work without getting his shot?
Question 4. Can she be held liable for putting her other employees at risk if they catch covid-19 from Kai?
Question 5. If they catch covid-19 from Kai can they heold Perfect Pizza, the franchisor liable?
Question 6. If you were a judge, would you find this was a "wrongful discharge" under Oregon law?

Case 2:

Two borthers, Sam and Tony owned ST-EX a small partnership that provided delivery service using three vans. Both worked in the business along with three employees. They contracted with several local bicycle shops to deliver parts from manufacturer warehouses--usually in one hour--so the shops could promise their customers "same day repairs." This worked out really well and kept two of the vans busy every day. The vans were always back at business by 4 o'clock. Sam managed the office & Tony himself used the third van to deliver pastries to suburban offices. When the covid-19 virus required restaurants to close their dining rooms, Sam contracted with several restaurants to make take-out deliveries after 4 o'clock--and the vans were now busy from 8 am to 10 pm.
Although Tony was only in his 30s, his doctor warned him that he might die if he contracted the virus due to his serious asthma and he needed to stay and "shelter" at home. Instead, Tony rented an apartment in Arizona and moved there leaving his brother to manage ST-EX for both of them. With the vans busy 15 hours a day and Tony unable to drive, Dam thought ST-EX needed a new 3rd driver. One of the drivers recommended his pal Kevin who had a clean driving record. Sam hired Kevin as an "independent contractor" because he thought he might need a 3rd driver for just a few months. Tony in Arizona, had no knowledge that Kevin, or anyone, was hired as a new driver.
One night Kevin made his first of two take-out deliveries in the van. On the way back from the first stop he made a side-trip of about three miles to pick up some dinner for himself at his favorite fish & chip shop. On his way back from the fish & chip shop he crashed the van into a new parked BMW while putting tarter sauce on the fish while he was driving. Kevin noticed a body shop still open, and its owner told him: "I'm wide open tomorrow--I can fix the van's dented fender for $1,000, but for $5,000 I can also paint the whole van and it will look like new." Without calling Sam, Kevin responded: "Great. We'll go for the whole paint job. My boss is good for it. I'll drop the van off tomorrow."

Required: Answer the following giving reasons for your conclusions. [Assume no car insurance is available]

Question 1. Kevin's accident was caught by a camera at a nearby 7-11 clearly showing the van plowing into the legally-parked BMW. Damage to the BMW is $10,000. Who is liable for the damage to the BMW--ST-EX or Kevin or both?

Question 2. Assume ST-EX is liable. Are Tony and Sam equally ultimately liable?

Question 3. Assume Sam has received the $5,000 body shop bill. Under agency law principles, is ST-EX liable on the deal Kevin made with the body shop?

Question 4. Assume ST-EX is found liable for the bill. Do Sam and Tony both have to pay $2,500, a smaller amount, or perhaps nothing?

Reference no: EM133194408

Questions Cloud

He wants an entity form that will minimize his tax liability : LAW 101 Saudi electronic university - select one you feel satisfies his concerns. Make sure to explain why it is the best for Ahmad and Pennypacker
What are the three ratings of candidate performance : What are the 3 ratings of candidate performance? What happens to interns who do not pass the edTPA by the second attempt?
What is the pineal gland primary function : Name the three membranous coverings of the Central Nervous System in order, beginning with the outermost layer. What is the Pineal Gland's primary function
How the example of external communication : How the example of external communication that you provided is appropriate for its intended audience.
What facts suggest kai is really an employee : University of Portland - What facts suggest Kai is really an employee not an independent contractor? and how does this affect Kai's legal rights here
Write the cultural analysis of the image : But you will need to be able to culturally analyze these images (by race, gender or class or a combination of those) so keep in mind when making your choice
Define bacteria and archaea : Define Bacteria and archaea. Discuss whether or not archaea has a role in human health and disease
Describe two effective virtual communication situations : Briefly describe one or two effective virtual communication situations and one or two that were ineffective, providing the context and purpose of each.
Discuss function of each of the cellular structures : Read about Eukaryotic cells and eukaryote organisms in your textbook. Discuss function of each of the cellular structures

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Discuss ethical concerns with the business scenario

The purpose of this assignment is to select the best organizational form, and to discuss ethical concerns with the business scenario.

  Discuss problem on higher education act

In 1965, the Higher Education Act allowed for expanded access to higher education by providing federal financial aid. Fast forward over 50 years.

  Assignment- elements of a crime

Assignment: Elements of a Crime, While passing Makoto's house one night, Sarah sees a laptop computer left unattended on Makoto's porch. Sarah takes the computer, carries it home, and tells everyone she owns it

  What trends or patterns are worth noting for the nation

What information is particularly important for the region your county is located in? Do you anticipate that your county will be specifically impacted by any of the conditions that are listed for the week? Why or why not?

  The discussion on nature versus nurture

The discussion on nature versus nurture is one that pits two philosophical frameworks against each other. Nature is the concept that biologically and in personality, humans possess gifts, traits, and abilities that make them the distinct individuals ..

  Explain who is correct in given contention

Hodge denies this and sues for specific performance, claiming that Voeller had actual and apparent authority to bind the partnership. The partners argue that Voeller had no such authority and that Hodge knew this. Who is correct? Explain.

  Wy are our conclusions from research considered tentative

why are our conclusions from research considered tentative? what is the continuing problem when attempting to show

  Report on the contracting process

You are required to prepare a four- to five-page report on the contracting process and the tools and techniques used to undertake the project

  Discusses about yick wo v. hopkins

Write a three page article that discusses about Yick Wo v. Hopkins

  Identify the parties who are before the court

Articulate the importance, context, purpose, and relevance of law in a business environment: Identify the parties who are before the court. Provide a brief background to problem. Summarize the facts in no more than 2-3 paragraphs

  Explain the four parts of the sara

Explain the four parts of the S.A.R.A. problem-solving process for police. Explain what the acronym SARA stands for and identify each of the four parts

  Did russell have title to the boat at the time of accident

Transamerica argued that the boat was not covered by the policy since Russell still owned it at the time of the accident.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd