What ethical values caused you to intervene

Assignment Help English

Reference no: EM133414643

Federal Government UHD Common Core Assignment

Essay Prompt
Hypothetical Situation1
Imagine walking into a village in another country. You find that a local military officer is about to shoot three people lined up against the wall. You ask, "Why are you shooting these people? They look quite harmless."

The officer says, "Last night somebody in this village shot one of my men. I know that somebody in this village is guilty, so I am going to shoot these three to set an example."

You say, "You can't do that! You're going to kill an innocent person. If only one shot was fired, then perhaps two of these people are innocent, perhaps all three. You just can't do that."

The officer takes a rifle from one of his men and hands it to you saying, "You shoot one of them for me and I'll let the other two go. You can save two lives if you shoot one of them. I'm going to teach you that in civil war you can't have these holier than thou attitudes."

Questions
In your own words, answer the following questions.

What ethical values caused "you" to intervene in this situation?
What assumptions about responsibility for life and death did you bring into this situation?
About guilt and innocence?
What about the military officer? What cultural or other circumstances could explain his actions?
1From Joseph Nye, Understanding International Conflicts (Longman, 2003), page 21.

To fully weigh your options, what other information, cultural or otherwise, would you need to know?
How could you find as solution that satisfies both your own personal ethical standards, and also your responsibilities to respect other cultures?
Finally, what choice do you make to resolve this problem?

Reference no: EM133414643

Questions Cloud

What could have caused the change in your opinion : Compare with the simulation result in lecture note 8. Does the configuration above result in any change to process cycle time and process wait time

Describe how you will approach an inventory of technology : Describe how you will approach an inventory of technology for your nursing department or unit and how you will prioritize your findings

Report from the indian river lagoon field trip : The Report from the Indian River Lagoon Field trip should be written in the format of a scientific paper

Provide important marketing data for healthcare : Reflect on when you have consumed a generic and brand-name product for the same health condition (e.g., taking Motrin and/or storing a brand of ibuprofen

What ethical values caused you to intervene : Federal Government UHD Common Core Assignment What ethical values caused "you" to intervene in this situation? What assumptions about responsibility for life

Global societal issue you have chosen : Background information on the global societal issue you have chosen. (Unemployment and lack of economic opportunity) - A brief argument supporting at least two

Evaluates a benchmark underperformance in a heath care : Evaluates a benchmark underperformance in a heath care organization or interprofessional team that has the potential for greatly improving overall quality

Explain the impact of a new policy and practice guidelines : Explain the impact of a new policy and practice guidelines. Offers clear insight into their implementation and effects on the role group's daily work routines

Need a paper written about the tv show breaking bad : Need a paper written about the TV show Breaking Bad and need to discuss the tension and theme of the show. more details will be provided. 3-4 pages

User Account

All Pages