What ethical case can be made in favor of this high pay

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM13801056 , Length: word count:300

Part 1:

1. Workers at Charney's America Apparel are the highest-paid mass-production sewers in the world.

< In terms of Charney's duties to the self, what ethical case can be made in favor of this high pay?

< In terms of Charney's duties to others, what ethical case can be made in favor of this high pay?

< Are these wages fair? Why or why not?

2. In terms of duties-either the perennial duties or Kant's categorical imperative-which is more recommendable: keeping the AA plant where and how it is, or moving it to Mexico and cutting the workers' wages in half? Why is the decision you've made the better of the two?

A few factors to consider:

< In Mexico, the workers' real pay in terms of local buying power would be much higher, even though the actual amount is less than what they receive here.

< Many of the workers are illegal immigrants from Mexico; their legal situation would obviously be remedied and proximity to family would increase.

< The national Mexican economy would benefit more from AA's presence than does the US economy.

3. Kant's categorical imperative requires that others be treated as ends and never as means.

< In what way could the argument be made that the employees at AA are being treated as means, and therefore Charney's plant is unethical no matter how high his salaries may be?

< Besides high pay, the company provides workers with considerable freedom to set their own work pace and schedule. The company also provides a stock purchase program. Do either or both of these factors alleviate the charge that the workers are treated as means and not ends? Why or why not?

4. Eighteen hundred of AA's five thousand workers were using false papers and Social Security numbers to get their job. Charney knew all about that but chose to overlook it.

< Leaving the law aside, how can that overlooking be justified ethically?

< Leaving the law aside, how can Kant be used to cast that action as ethically wrong in terms of lying? In terms of stealing? In terms of using people as means instead of ends?

< Charney and AA support illegal immigrants in two ways: by giving them jobs and by organizing popular protests in favor of their legalization. Ethically, are these two activities recommendable or not? Or is one recommendable and the other not?

5. Assuming it's wrong for illegal immigrants to be working in America, who deserves the sterner ethical reprobation, Charney or the illegal workers? Explain in ethical terms.

6. The basic and natural rights of mainstream rights theory include the following:
< Life

< Freedom

< Free speech

< Religious expression

< The pursuit of happiness

< Possessions and the fruits of our work

< How can these rights be mustered to support Charney's hiring and keeping workers he knows are in the country illegally?

< How can these rights be mustered to ethically denounce Charney for hiring and keeping workers he knows are in the country illegally?

< Thinking about those workers, do these rights give them an ethical license to use false Social Security numbers and identifying documents? Why or why not?

7. Eddy Lepp ended up in jail for his medicinal mar?uana garden, yet Charney sleeps in a million-dollar beach house. Is this fair?

Reference no: EM13801056

Questions Cloud

Calculate the potential energy of a system : Calculate the potential energy of a system of two small spheres, one carrying a charge of 2.50 µC and the other a charge of -3.50 µC, with their centers separated by a distance of 0.270m. Assume zero potential energy when the charges are infinitel..

Role of play in the overly-academic classroom : One of the hottest topics in early childhood education is the role of play in the classroom. Although early childhood educators understand the importance of incorporating play into a developmentally appropriate curriculum, many parents have a diff..

Demonstrate how the principles of the theory support : Demonstrate how the principles of the theory support a certain position on that question. Articulate a relevant objection to the theory on the basis of that argument.

Problems based on a correlation coefficient : What does it mean if two variables have an r value of 1? How are two variables related if they have an r value of .8? What about an r value of -.8

What ethical case can be made in favor of this high pay : What ethical case can be made in favor of this high pay - what ethical case can be made in favor of this high pay - How can these rights be mustered to ethically denounce Charney for hiring and keeping workers he knows are in the country illegally?

Example of positive parent-child : Think of experiences you have had with infants or toddlers, either professionally or personally. Describe an example of positive parent-child (or caregiver-child) communication you observed and an example of communication that was negative or har..

Current and emerging issues in the field : As an early childhood educator, it is important to stay up-to-date with current and emerging issues in the field. It is also important to be well-informed as you shape your viewpoints on these issues. For this journal, choose one of the following ..

Write essay about why write about literature mla formating : Write an essay about Why Write about Literature MLA formating.

Benefits of home-school partnerships : One of your most important roles as an early childhood educator will be to foster home-school partnerships. Discuss what you believe are the benefits of home-school partnerships.

User Account

All Pages