What effects or details did the designer ignore

Assignment Help Mechanical Engineering
Reference no: EM131312924 , Length: word count:1000

Equipment Engineering and Design Structural Failure Problem-

Background -

A 6 ton pressure vessel - see dimensioned drawing - was being lowered onto a "stillage"or temporary supporting structure for testing outside a factory in the open yard. The lower lugs were attached to the stillage and as the slings were being loosened by the crane operator, the vessel tilted slightly. 

At this point one of the legs of the stillage collapsed.  Luckily the slings had not been removed, so the vessel did not fall - but a serious accident was only narrowly averted.

It was subsequently noticed that the ground on which the vessel and stillage were being placed sloped at 5 degrees.

367_Figure.png

Problem -

1. Why did the leg collapse? What effects or details did the designer ignore?

2. Redesign the stillage to avoid similar incidents in future, without increasing its footprint (width, length) since space is needed around it for testing.

3. Make recommendations on safe lifting and mechanical handling of the vessel.

Tips: work out the weight and the centre of gravity of the vessel. Check the load on each leg. Estimate the collapse load using a suitable formula and relevant assumptions.

Also look up the rules for similar mechanical handling procedures

Vessel details -

Wall thickness 12mm. Hemispherical ends. Carbon steel.

Overall length 7.2m, diameter 2.4m

3 Nozzles (all on vessel centre line), pipe o/d 500mm, i/d 420mm, 500mm long.

Nozzle flanges, o/d 600mm, i/d 420mm, thickness 22mm

Stillage details -

Section: 50 x 50 x 5 mm rolled steel angle. Welded construction. S275 steel (i.e. yield stress of 275 MPa).

Section Properties: overall width 2m, length 4.4m, height 2.4m.

787_Figure1.png

Reminder of the Euler critical loads Pc which are valid for slenderness ratio l/k > 80. What are the actual end conditions here?

644_Figure2.png

The calculation aspect should be on the appendix but will be referenced on the main body of the work.

Reference no: EM131312924

Questions Cloud

Immediately speed up the project : Your project is executed with a globally spread virtual team. The project progress has been found to be too slow. Which measure is most likely to immediately speed up the project? Answer in 4-5 sentences.
Estimate how much you need to increase the planform area : Estimate how much you need to increase the planform area of the horizontal stabilizer to maintain the same static margin in pitch. Assume for simplicity no change in the cg location.
Proposals according to a standard format : Why would a customer give contractors instructions in the RFP to submit their proposals according to a standard format?
What would be the complexity if the list were sorted : Given an unsorted list of n values, what is the time-complexity to find the kth smallest value in the worst case? What would be the complexity if the list were sorted?
What effects or details did the designer ignore : 55 - 7947 Equipment Engineering and Design Structural Failure Problem. A 6 ton pressure vessel - see dimensioned drawing - was being lowered onto a "stillage"or temporary supporting structure for testing outside a factory in the open yard. Why did ..
Proprietorship or partnership to become a corporation : What do you give up as an owner of a proprietorship or partnership to become a corporation? What does it mean to you as an owner to have limited or unlimited liability? How does a corporation differ when a stockholder or manager dies compared to when..
Create a 4 period moving average forecast : Create a 4-period moving average forecast, an exponential smoothing forecast with alpha=0.2, and a linear trend forecast for your data.
Think about a specific healthcare organization : Think about a specific healthcare organization: Are there any differences for creating an effective delivery system? Who are the important stakeholders in a healthcare delivery system?
What will stock price be in three years : The Jackson–Timberlake Wardrobe Co. just paid a dividend of $1.65 per share on its stock. The dividends are expected to grow at a constant rate of 5 percent per year indefinitely. Investors require a return of 12 percent on the company's stock. What ..

Reviews

len1312924

12/15/2016 2:19:21 AM

UK student, total 1000 words, need it as per the guidelines. Tips: work out the weight and the centre of gravity of the vessel. Check the load on each leg. Estimate the collapse load using a suitable formula and relevant assumptions. Also look up the rules for similar mechanical handling procedures. All Theory and discussions must be directed and related to this problem. Lists of general/generic design issues, management techniques etc are not acceptable and will lose marks; all discussions must be related to the problem at hand.

Write a Review

Mechanical Engineering Questions & Answers

  Package design

Package Design Brief: Assume you are the packaging engineer for a large consumer products company. In this company, the Packaging Design Briefs are initiated by the marketing group and forwarded to the Package Engineering group.

  Mechanical engineering questions

Define dynamic viscosity, Determine the centroid, Pressure due to the height of liquid, Advantage of changing the liquid, Calculate the total moment about the hinge of the seal gate.

  Automatic control

DOF system and Find the differential equation describing the system

  Write a paper on boyle''s law

Write a paper on Boyle's law and describe Compression and Combustion stroke . Also explain Charles's law and illustrate SI engine and CI engine.

  Verify the law for parallelogram of forces

To Verify the law for parallelogram of forces, law for triangle of forces and law of polygon of forces. These laws are very useful to calculate unknown forces in very short time.

  Discharge pressure of the compressor

What is the discharge revised discharge pressure of the compressor.

  The Case for Global Accounting Standards

The role of IFRS in both developing and developed capital markets.

  Wind turbine

Wind turbines are becoming more and more common as a method of energy production, wind turbines by their very nature are dynamic and are subject to and create their own internal and external kinematics and kinetics.

  Advanced design methodologies

8 x product engineering and design review (week 2 – 12), ~3 pages per item which must contain a brief description of the product then delve into concepts such as materials selection, manufacturing methods, life cycle analysis, recyclability and overa..

  Design of absorption column and the cooler

Design of absorption column and the cooler. Process design of other units should be completed along with pipe sizes.

  Determine the maximum total bending moment

Determine maximum total bending moment (static plus dynamic) of the beam under steady-state conditions.

  Force of the water on the gate

Determine the magnitude of the horizontal and vertical components of the force of the water on the gate.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd