What does the hedonistic utilitarian say we should do

Assignment Help Humanities
Reference no: EM133613060

Assignment:

1. How would you define happiness? Is it something that can be defined at all? What is its relationship to pleasure? Are they the same or different? Why?

Can you think of a situation where the right thing to do seems to depend on how the happiness is distributed as opposed to the total amount of it? (Note that Mill's theory does not speak to how the happiness should be distributed.) If so, describe it.

2. I'll start with an example: I have 100 pieces of candy.

Act A: I give 100 friends each one piece of candy.

Act B: I gave all the candy to my greedy friend Sally.

Let's suppose Sally does not get sick from all that candy, but becomes extremely happy, 100 times happier than any of the people who would have received one piece. Mill's GHP would say each act - distributing to everyone or giving it all to Sally - in this case is equally good. But does this seem like the right result? Doesn't it seem unfair to give it all to Sally? If it seems unfair, and if "unfair" seems intuitively to be "morally wrong", then we have an objection to Mill's theory about moral rightness.

3. Mill's Greatest Happiness Principle (GHP) is this:

"The doctrine that the basis of morals is utility, or the greatest happiness principle, holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong in proportion as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness." (top left-hand side of p. 5, Utilitarianism)

Describe an act and justify it by appeal to Mill's GHP (that is, make the case that the act will result in greater overall happiness than not doing it).

Example: A man who owns 100 acres of forest land decides to donate 20 acres for a park and campground that can be enjoyed by many people. Without having more details, this on the face of it would be justified on utilitarian grounds in that it would increase the overall amount of happiness, assuming there is no one who would be made unhappy by the man giving away his land.

4. Utilitarianism and Ethical Egoism, as two opposing theories in ethics, have something in common. What is it? (If several people have already posted a correct answer you cannot use your answer here to earn a "make-up point" )

5. Hedonistic utilitarianism is the view that the moral rightness of an act consists in the amount of pleasure it produces. Mill is usually considered a hedonistic utilitarian although he does distinguish not only between amount of pleaure but quality of pleasure, with some pleasures being higher.

Let's say there's a cake, and only one piece left. We must dispose of the cake now - we can't save it for later. We are both hungry. Do I get the cake or do you? Or do we divide it in half or
divide it up some other way?

(a) What does the hedonistic utilitarian say we should do?

(b) What if eating cake makes me extremely deliriously happy, while you gain only a normal amount of pleasure from it? Let's say I would get 10 times as much pleasure as you would eating that cake. What does the hedonistic utilitarian say in that case?

Reference no: EM133613060

Questions Cloud

What mistakes did miles make with his confidential records : What mistakes did Miles make with his confidential records? How could he have better secured this confidential information?
Legal concept of breach of implied contract : Determining whether an employee has been constructively discharged. What is meant by the legal concept of breach of implied contract?
Innovation in the organization : Innovation in the Organization Identify the step in the innovation process at which the following actions are most likely to occur.
Evaluate the district attorneys statement : Texas has the right to set moral standards of its people. Evaluate the district attorney's statement. Is this an argument? Are there any fallacies?
What does the hedonistic utilitarian say we should do : Mill is usually considered a hedonistic utilitarian although he does distinguish not only between amount of pleaure but quality of pleasure.
Which type of program do you think provides the most benefit : Which type of program do you think provides the most benefit to victims? To offenders? To derivative victims? Explain your answer.
Organization can be confident that strategy yields : An organization can be confident that its strategy yields a competitive advantage after: it has earned above-average returns for at least two years in a row
What kind of evidence supports the model of spinning : What kind of evidence supports the model of spinning, heating and flattening in the formation of the solar system and other star systems?
Would a sample of this dusty atmosphere be a mixture : Suppose there is a dust storm due to the winds blowing dry soil into the air. Would a sample of this dusty atmosphere be a mixture

Reviews

Write a Review

Humanities Questions & Answers

  Plan to improve correctional facilities

Women imprisonment should be facilitate with certain correctional facilities. In this paper, we have discussed about the plan for improving correctional facilities for the women prisoner in America.

  Situation analysis of food security in new zealand

This paper aims to present, discuss and analyse factors that are causing low food security, the management, current and proposed solutions in New Zealand (NZ).

  Social services on human traffic

The research study is limited to the understanding of  how social service agencies could approach or respond to the needs of the victim/ survivor of sex trafficking.

  Social deviance: the issue of risky sexual behaviour

The issue of deviant behaviour has been discussed by various sociologists from a number of perspectives.

  Race and racism

This paper is a brief description of the study, discrimination pertains to the prejudice perception and treatment of a person or demographical issues belonging to a category.

  Depth of challenges people face

Your own knowledge about the Depth of Challenges People face

  Project plan written report

Sufficient information to enable the organisation's Board of Executives to understand the rationale for the program and the activities required to design, implement and evaluate the program including any additional data that would need to be colle..

  Evaluation structure logical and achievable.

Health care organisational processes management, service administration, service provision and delivery

  Write an essay on locke''s theory of meaning

Write an essay on Locke's theory of meaning

  Leadership reflections paper

Write a paper on Leadership Reflections Paper Summarizes and reflects upon leadership ideas gleaned from the four required readings

  What role has feminism played

what role has feminism played in our appreciation of their work today.

  What subject matter choices were available to women artists

Prior to the beginning of the twentieth century, what subject matter choices were available to women artists? What cultural and historical influences placed limitations on their choices?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd