What do you think was the motivation for cubbies cable

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131380236

Ernie Binks is a big baseball fan, so it is quite natural for him, at a time like this, to recall a phrase attributed to Yogi Berra: "It was déjà vu all over again." Binks is the partner in charge of the Cubbies Cable audit for the accounting firm of Santos & Williams LLP. Cubbies is a publicly-owned cable company headquartered in Chicago. A situation arose with the client over the proper accounting for cable installation costs in the year-ended September 30, 2013, financial statements.

The client wants to expense the costs while the audit manager has recommended capitalization. It is important to resolve the issue quickly because the client will use the September 30, 2013, audited annual statements to apply for a $10 million loan at one of two banks- Chicago First National or Bankers Trust. Binks reviewed a memorandum prepared by John Kessinger, the audit manager, that details the accounting issues. This memo is presented in Exhibit 1. The revenue earned from the cable installation job enabled the company to complete the fourth quarter of 2013 with Case 7-3 Cubbies Cable record earnings. Revenues at September 30, 2013, exceeded revenues at September 30, 2012, by 22 percent.

Net income for the twelve months ended September 30, 2013, was 24 percent above the same amount in the prior year. Binks is now preparing for a meeting with Rod Hondley, the advisory partner on the Cubbies Cable audit. Hondley has already made it known that he supports the client's position on the cable installation costs. Binks knows Santos & Williams operates by the simple philosophy that you have to let the client win one somewhere along the line or you may lose that client.

The dilemma for Binks is he is in the uncomfortable position of going against the recommendation of the audit manager if he agrees to the client's position that Hondley supports. Binks thinks about the fact that the situation is unique in that the client's preferred accounting treatment would actually lower earnings for the year-ended September 30, 2013, and increase it in subsequent years. He considers his options and reflects on another "Yogi-ism": "When you come to a fork in the road, take it."

Questions
1. What do you think was the motivation for Cubbies Cable in taking the position to expense all cable costs during the year ended September 20, 2013. Would you characterize the position as an attempt to manage earnings? Why or why not?

2. Who are the stakeholders in this situation? Identify the major ethical issues that should be of concern to Binks in deciding whether to just go along with the firm in its support of the client (based on Hondley's position) or support the position of the audit manager. What would you do if you were in Binks's position? Why?

3. Do you think it is ethical for CPAs to "horse trade" when negotiating with a client about the proper GAAP to apply in a particular situation? How does such negotiating relate to the accepted auditing standards of the AICPA and PCAOB discussed?

Reference no: EM131380236

Questions Cloud

How would you characterize the proposed accrual : How would you characterize the proposed accrual for unpaid bonuses and severance payments from an earnings management perspective?

Explain how culture impacts how you communicate : Explain how culture impacts how you communicate with others, including those from different cultures - Define culture and explain why it is important to understanding communication.

Do the variables politics and sex appear to be independent : What percent of the seniors are planning to attend a 2-year college?

Compare two sources of financing you might obtain : FIN 100- Suppose you need $1 million dollars to start your Dream Business. Research ways to get the money for such a business. Compare two sources of financing you might obtain.

What do you think was the motivation for cubbies cable : What do you think was the motivation for Cubbies Cable in taking the position to expense all cable costs during the year ended September 20, 2013.

Analyze what it means to reduce recidivism : Analyze what it means to reduce recidivism according to the varying definitions of recidivism. What types of variables need to be considered when determining whether or not a program or treatment reduces recidivism?

What types of financial shenanigans were used by the trio : Auditors are required to assess fraud risks as part of their ethical and professional responsibilities. What characteristics of Nortel might have caused it to be identified as a high-risk audit? Use the fraud triangle in answering this question.

How tendencies in the ways males and females communicate : Describe how tendencies in the ways males and females communicate can both help and hurt them in various communicative exchanges.

Find the relative frequency distribution of the decisions : Find the relative frequency distribution of the decisions made, and write a sentence describing it.

User Account

All Pages