What do you think of idea

Reference no: EM133288475

The Concept

Richard Rodriguez writes of a painful duality, a "disabling confusion," caused by speaking one language at school and another at home (27). However, he posits that "bilingualists simplistically scorn the value and necessity of assimilation" (Rodriguez 25). A crucial facet of his argument is that Rodriguez credits being forced to speak only English at school, and eventually being forced to speak it at home, with becoming successful in his career and with becoming "an American citizen." What do you think of this idea?

The Task

After considering Rodriguez' controversial ideas, find a quote that illustrates some aspect of his argument. Post the quote and an analysis of its meaning: what is Rodriguez saying here? Then explain whether you agree or disagree-or some combination thereof-and why. Though your post should be primarily focused on analyzing Rodriguez' ideas, feel free to also allude to a personal experience if you find it relevant.

The Purpose

The point of this discussion, as you prepare for Essay #3, is to help you think more deeply about the ideas of language, identity, and education.

Post Two Replies

After you type your initial post, read through the other entries and reply directly to at least two classmates and/or your professor. When you reply, please respond to a specific idea from the post, as well as any other constructive comments you wish to make. Your replies should each be at least 25 words long.

Reminder

Since your discussion posts for this course constitute a portion of the academic writing you will complete this term, make sure to use proper grammar, formal language, including capitalization ("I" instead of "i"), and correct punctuation in this college level course in all correspondence. Please avoid "text" or "twitter speak" when corresponding.

Reference no: EM133288475

Questions Cloud

History on the basis of thomas kings story : ENG 1440 University of Winnipeg "What's to like? It's all history. You can't mock around with history. It is not always the way we'd like it to be but there it

Does the writer seem to support the point : Explain why the following criteria for evaluation is important to your assessment of a published piece and Does the writer seem to support the point with good

Explain the nature of the parent material to soil formation : Explain the importance of the nature of the parent material to soil formation and type.

What did you do to make yourself feel better : ENG 101 Arizona State University What were the circumstances? What did you do to make yourself feel better? What might you do to avoid feeling this way

What do you think of idea : ENGL 102 Coastline Community College eventually being forced to speak it at home, with becoming successful in his career and with becoming "an American citizen

What else do you think a fiji ocean use survey : What else do you think a Fiji Ocean Use Survey could be utilized for? Your suggestions can be additional questions you think the community would like to answer.

Find evidence that accused of a crime : Find evidence that accused of a crime didn't have the right to confront one's accusers. They were not given the opportunity to confront their accusers

Introduction of colonial education which halted the growth : In fact, prior to embracing colonial rule, the African continent was developing with its own indigenous patten of education rooted in African technology.

Analyze how the character attempts reconciliation : Analyze how the character attempts reconciliation, successful or not, and how that attempt contributes to the meaning of the work as a whole

User Account

All Pages