What differentiates each of these three beds

Reference no: EM133262524

Question: The dialogue between Socrates and Glaucon in Book X of The Republic features an unsettling number of beds. Plato writes:

Well, then, it turns out there are three kinds of beds. One exists in nature. I suppose we would say god created it. Who else could?

No one else, I should think.

And then the bed the carpenter made.

Yes.

And the one made by the painter. Right?

All right.

So we have the painter, the carpenter, and god. These three produce three kinds of beds.

Three. Right.

God, then, whether he willed it or because he felt some constraint not to make more than one bed, did in fact make only one bed, the real bed. Never were two or more beds made by god, nor would they ever be.

Why not?

I shall explain. Even if he had made only two beds, a third would unavoidably appear. That would be the real bed, of which the other two would only be copies. (79-80)

Socrates's conclusion is stunning, and the writers we studied during week one-Saussure and Derrida and Bakhtin-spent their careers responding to it.

what differentiates each of these three beds: How is God's bed unlike a painter's bed and unlike a joiner's? What should be offer to both Saussure's and Derrida's response to Socrates's argument

Reference no: EM133262524

Questions Cloud

What are three ways you can support social competence : ECE 299 Charter Oak State College What are three ways you can support social and emotional competence within a caring and equitable community? (Montessori presc

Support an interaction hypothesis : Q: What is the evidence to support an interaction hypothesis between the first and second screen. Under what circumstances is such interaction most likely to oc

Explain why the execution went well or not so well : 1. How has a company you have worked with or for used double loop management and SMART to ensure strong feedback loops in strategy?

How cultural diversity influences community : How Cultural Diversity influences Community and Public Health Nursing? Illustrate an interdisciplinary approach to improvement of the healthcare outcomes

What differentiates each of these three beds : What differentiates each of these three beds: How is God's bed unlike a painter's bed and unlike a joiner's? What should be offer to both Saussure's

Walmart external environment : Write a report that shows how you analyzed Walmart's external environment, internal capabilities and resources, and its strategic options.

Describe how the varied structure of different types of text : ELM 305 Grand Canyon University Discuss why it is important for content area teachers to present information using both informative/expository and imaginative

What a manufacturing process is : 1. What a manufacturing process is and identify the different ways it can be organized.

Discuss why unions are important in the workplace : Discuss why unions are important in the workplace. Examine the challenges for unions and employers in the modern workplace

User Account

All Pages