What decision benefits the greatest number

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133478491

Case: Apple and the FBI have two separate incidences where the FBI has asked Apple to break into an iPhone in a terrorist investigation where that phone may contain information that could prevent another terrorist attack. I have attached a case study that details the incident in 2015 and I have included a link to a New York Times article that details the incident earlier this year. For purposes of this discussion, you are Tim Cook and you must decide how to respond to the FBI's latest request. Falling back on his business studies, Mr. Cook applies utilitarianism to analyze what his decision should be.

Who are the stakeholders in this and how might they be affect by Apple's decision?
The stakeholders in the situation that would be affected are obviously the customers, large companies that use and even sell apple products. On the other hand stakeholder could also be considered are law enforcement, victims and even criminals. On both ends the biggest item that is affected by this decision either way is privacy.
What decision benefits the greatest number of these stakeholders?

In this immediate situation the biggest number of people effected are the customers, owners and distributors of apple products.
Do you agree with the decision that utilitarianism leads you to? Why or why not?

In this case I don't degree because this is a matter of national security. And in hindsight apple essentially did it anyway by referring them to a company that had the means to backdoor the software, so honestly there was no difference. That's like saying I wont kill you but im going to pay someone to do it. Now on the other side I do agree because a private person I don't want someone to be able to access my personal device whenever they see fit even though I have nothing to hide.

Does apply the test in Rights and Duties or Fairness and Justice lead you to a different answer?

As a military Iean more toward yes, however I believe that black and white are there for a reason but we are allowed to operate in the grey area as long as it is morally and ethically right.

Reference no: EM133478491

Questions Cloud

How ict is affecting work and personal life boundaries : What are some major concerns about employees having excess to work systems during their non-work period? How can this pose threats to businesses?

What will the court decide. find law, analysis, remedies : even if the exclusion clause does not apply, it should not be held liable for $700 000 because it did not know all the details concerning the contract

Why would these men at the top of their respective games : Mark Cuban kept his job but was sanctioned by the NBA! Why would these men at the TOP of their respective games all have the same problem?

Which theory do you find most thought-provoking : HW 410 Purdue Global University - Select two psychological theories from Chapter 5. Managing Stress: Skills for Self-Care, Personal Resiliency and Work-Life

What decision benefits the greatest number : What decision benefits the greatest number of these stakeholders and Does apply the test in Rights and Duties or Fairness and Justice lead you to a different

Different types of private networks : Classify the three different types of Private Networks. Compare the two different Internet security standards of IPsec and SLL/TLS in terms of features

What you have learned in the employment law : What you have learned in the employment law module to the situation. Identify any potential issues and explore the implications

Prepare and record an oral and visual presentation : Prepare and record an oral and visual presentation of your policy analysis PowerPoint to your client.

Introduce to the canadian income tax system : You will learn how the system of Canadian income taxes was created, who is required/liable to tax and, what income is subject to tax.

User Account

All Pages