Reference no: EM13973994
"The Evolution of Bank Supervision"
In general, referee reports contain three sections.
(1) The first is a brief paragraph that says, in your own words, what the paper is about. (Note: repeating or paraphrasing the abstract of the paper does not satisfy this requirement.) This paragraph is important in that it establishes whether or not you understood the basic point of the paper.
(2) The second section is most important-this is where you note two to four major points that you have with the paper. For example, the authors write a paper about the effect of X on Y, but their data is only a proxy for X-one major point you would raise is whether the effect estimated can really be of X on Y. If the model does has no relationship to the empirical approach, this is where such points are made.
(3) The third section details minor points such as misspellings, confusing phrasing, grammar, etc. On the course website you will find two notes that detail how referee reports work. These have been taken from course syllabi in other courses and you should use them as a guide for your own referee reports.
Referee reports are not reaction papers. They are your honest and thorough assessment of the scholarly value of the paper in question. By this stage in your education you should be able to evaluate scholarship critically and offer a well-justified assessment of the research of others. Your report you will need to show that you understand the author's paper and that you understand how it fits into the literature. Most important, you will need to draw on your knowledge of economics, econometrics and the related literature to assess the value of the paper. In doing so you need to point out how the paper can be improved and/or extended. If you are not convinced by an argument in the paper, explain why. If something is confusing, point it out. If the author does not properly summarize the work of others, point that out as well. It is fine to be critical (and you are expected to be), but you should aim to be constructive above all. What could the author do to make that research more convincing? What could reasonably be done to improve the paper?
Attachment:- The Evolution of Bank Supervision 2014.rar
|
Used computer system sales inc
: 1. Used Computer System Sales, Inc. (UCSSI), which began its operations in July of 2007, specialized in the purchase, sale, distribution, upgrade, and repair of new, as well as refurbished, equipment for the Sun Microsystems/Oracle America marke..
|
|
Problem regarding the adjusting entry-edson corp
: The face value of the note was $153,000. Edson used a "Discount on Note Payable" account to initially record the note and the discount will be amortized equally over the 3-month period. What is the adjusting entry made at December 31, 2011?
|
|
Using the data below the month of july
: Using the data below the month of July, determine the July Gross Profit using FIFO inventory methods.June 30:
|
|
What type of domain does it come from
: Is it published by an entity that makes sense? Who "published" the page? Equally important, please post websites that you are not sure about their validity, so that we, as a class, can discuss.
|
|
What could author do to make that research more convincing
: What could the author do to make that research more convincing? What could reasonably be done to improve the paper?
|
|
Differential reinforcement of other behavior
: Decide which of the following concepts are most applicable to each scenario: differential reinforcement of other behavior, avoidance contingency, punishment by prevention of reinforcer, punishment by loss of reinforcer, or avoidance of loss.
|
|
Canadian income taxes
: SMALLco is a domestic corporation that has elected S corporation status. SMALLco wholly owns a Canadian corporation, CANco. CANco earns $100,000 of income during the year and pays $40,000 in Canadian income taxes.
|
|
What is its bond equivalent yield
: a. What is the price of the bill? (Use 360 days a year. Do not round intermediate calculations. Round your answer to 2 decimal places.) Price of the bill =$ 9900.33 b. What is its bond equivalent yield? (Use 365 days a year. Do not round intermedi..
|
|
Impairment loss included in continuing operations
: What before-tax amount(s) should Pearman report as loss on discontinued operations in its 2016 income statement? $1,400,000 loss. $400,000 loss. None. $400,000 impairment loss included in continuing operations and a $1,000,000 loss from discontinu..
|