What arguments would support matts refusal to pay

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133579045

Case: Matt agrees to pay AP Plumbing $100 to clear a blocked sewer line in Matt's house. While clearing the sewer line, AP Plumbing's line snake tool got stuck in the pipes leading from Matt's house to the main sewer. To get it out, AP Plumbing had to dig a large hole in Matt's yard to access the underground sewer line.

When AP Plumbing dug the hole, they uncovered the water pipes for Matt's house which ran underground next to the sewer line. The water pipes had multiple leaks, some severe. To be up to code, the lines would need to be replaced at some time, either immediately or at a later date when they would have to be dug up again at greater expense.

AP Plumbing replaced the water pipes without asking Matt. The whole time AP Plumbing worked in the yard, Matt stood at the edge of the hole and watched. He never objected to the replacement of the pipes.

AP Plumbing gave Matt a bill for $200 ($100 for clearing the line, and $100 for replacing the water lines). Matt refused to pay any part of the bill, so AP Plumbing sued Matt.

Questions:

Based on the situation above, write in detail in response to each of the questions. Your responses should incorporate relevant contract law.

1. What arguments would support Matt's refusal to pay the bill?

2. What arguments would support AP Plumbing's claim?

3. Who should win and why?

Reference no: EM133579045

Questions Cloud

Discuss which staff issues should be taken into account : Discuss which staff issues should be taken into account when introducing an evidence-based change in practice. Discuss why/how EBP is incorporated into QI.

Which may exacerbate conflicts : which may exacerbate conflicts. Clear and effective communication is essential to prevent and manage conflicts in various settings, including healthcare

Walmart files an appeal with the united states supreme : walmart files an appeal with the united states supreme court. the court does not hear the case

How can flexibility influence a leader : whom you have worked using more than one of the style of leadership explained in this chapter. Would this improve his or her abilities as a leader?

What arguments would support matts refusal to pay : What arguments would support Matts refusal to pay the bill? 2. What arguments would support AP Plumbing's claim

Describes the entire process in which holden was engaging : he acquired information, stored it, retrieved it, and used it to complete his job. Which concept best describes the entire process in which Holden was engaging?

Conduct may give rise to personal jurisdiction : Conduct may give rise to personal jurisdiction if the defendant could have foreseen that his actions might avail him to the laws of some other jurisdiction

Analyze the greatest department store on earth : Analyze this cartoon titled "The Greatest Department Store on Earth," from Puck magazine (November 29, 1899).

Discuss effective practices in establishing performance : Discuss effective practices in establishing performance expectations for supervisees or trainees in behavior analyst using examples.

User Account

All Pages