What are the important policy interests at odds in wrongful

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133423885

Case Study: White Plains Coat & Apron Co. is a New York based linen rental business. Cintas Corp., is a nationwide business that rents similar products. White Plains had five-year exclusive contracts with some of its customers. As a result of Cintas soliciting of business, dozens of White Plains customers breached their contracts and entered into rental agreements with Cintas. White Plains demanded that Cintas stop its solicitation of White Plains customers. Cintas refused. White Plains filed suit in federal district court against Cintas, alleging wrongful interference with existing contracts. Cintas argued that it had no knowledge of any contracts with White Plains and had not induced any breach. The court dismissed the suit, ruling that Cintas had a legitimate interest as a competitor to solicit business and make a profit. White Plains appealed to the US Court of Appeals of the 2nd Circuit.

Questions:

a) What are the 2 important policy interests at odds in wrongful interference cases? Which of these interests should be accorded priority?

b) The US Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit Court asked the New York Court of Appeals to answer a question: Is a general interest in soliciting business for profit a sufficient defense to a claim of wrongful interference with a contractual relationship? What do you think? Why?

Reference no: EM133423885

Questions Cloud

Create a worksheet that will allow someone to plug : Create a worksheet that will allow someone to plug in the number of hours of parking they will need per week and decide whether HONK hourly, or a monthly

What other aspects of franchising positive and negative : These and other attributes of franchises can lessen some of the risks of the marketplace. What other aspects of franchising - positive and negative

Planning and identifying processes and techniques : Planning and identifying processes and techniques involved in designing the prototype (please list the steps you followed to design the prototype

Why are dhs strategic goals important to us stability : What is a good thesis statement and conclusion on why are DHS strategic goals important to U.S. stability and homeland security.

What are the important policy interests at odds in wrongful : What are the 2 important policy interests at odds in wrongful interference cases? Which of these interests should be accorded priority?

Calculate the accuracy, precision : In a binary classification task, we have 10 samples/records, if our classification results are: {0,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,1,1}, while the real

What are the features of the law : Select a federal healthcare law other than the ACA that has been passed in the last 50 years. What are the features of the law? Is the law effective?

Did cogdill have a contract with the bank of benton : The bank's president Julio Plunkett thanked Buster for the proposal and said, "I will start the paperwork." Did Cogdill have a contract with the Bank of Benton?

How did the media portray the police : Discussed on page 46 did the incident contain? Explain. How did the media portray the police? Was it a fair portrayal or was the media biased? Explain.

User Account

All Pages