What are the different consequences of coercing

Reference no: EM133448029

First, give Mill's account of the limits of Governmental and Social Coercion. Be sure to give and explain the Principle of Liberty and explain how Mill's reasoning is Utilitarian. Next, apply Mill's theory to a specific contemporary debate regarding coercion - that is, carefully consider how a Millian should side in a specific contemporary issue. Be sure to carefully weigh all the considerations that would matter to giving a Millian analysis of the problem (does the act to be coerced against cause significant harm to identifiable others, what are the different consequences of coercing and not coercing, etc.?)

Finally, argue whether the Millian analysis you gave is correct - in one of the two following ways.

Option 1: If you think Mill's theory gets it right, then give Mill's arguments (using your debate as an example) for why only harm to others should count as grounds for coercion. Be sure to at least consider a serious objection to your conclusion.

Option 2: If you think the Millian analysis is wrong, then give arguments that it is wrong, using your debate as an example (e.g., argue that there is reason to coerce on the grounds of Paternalism, Legal Moralism, Lockean Property Rights, or Contractarianism. That is, argue that Mill's theory requires us to ignore considerations that should play a role in determining whether coercion is justified).

Reference no: EM133448029

Questions Cloud

Explain why credibility, validity, ethical guidelines : Explain why credibility, validity, ethical guidelines, and accuracy are all important in regard to your research topic and to any research within

Describe the main idea of the theory and its strengths : analysis of one organizational theory. In your analysis, describe the main idea of the theory and its strengths and limitations as applied to social work

Describe the three stages of muslim religious identity : Describe the three stages of Muslim religious identity development as outlined in the reading. Peek interviewed her study participants shortly after 9/11/2001.

Which would be a concise statement of gratitude : Which would be a concise statement of gratitude, identifying the ethical and intellectual debts, the statement of gratitude should be genuine.

What are the different consequences of coercing : what are the different consequences of coercing and not coercing - That is, argue that Mill's theory requires us to ignore considerations that should play

How can the anti oppresive theoratical framework be used : how have persons with disability been discriminated against in the employment sector even with the exisitance of the employment equity policy in ontario?

How long did take ancestral waterfall to cover the distance : How long did it take the ancestral waterfall to cover the distance from the downtown St. Paul area to the juncture at fort snelling?

What kind of person would make the best teacher : What kind of person would make the best teacher? How does this view reflect major ideas within reconstructionist philosophy? Assess the effectiveness of teacher

What formal organization uses instrumental leadership style : What formal organization uses instrumental leadership style in your personal life? How would the organization behave differently if they used a democratic

User Account

All Pages