What are some of the challenges in the current peer-review

Reference no: EM133577930

Discussion Post

Dr. Henry Walton Jones, Jr was asked to review an article entitled, "The Golden Idol: Insights into the Inca Empire." for the Journal of Archaeological Research. The lead author of the paper is Dr. Rene Emile Belloq, a primary rival of Dr. Jones. Please provide your thoughts on the following scenarios (no more than a few sentences per question):

Question I. What types of conflict of interest might arise when someone is asked to review a paper or grant application?

Question II. Dr. Jones has been away from his office on travel for the past few weeks and does not have time to review the paper. Is it ever appropriate for a peer reviewer to give a paper to a graduate student for review? If so, how should the reviewer do so?

Question III. Dr. Jones was also pursuing research related to the Golden Idol. Is it appropriate for a peer reviewer to use ideas from an article under review to stop unfruitful research in the reviewer's laboratory?

Question IV. What are some of the challenges in the current peer-review process, in which the peer reviewer is anonymous but the author is known to the reviewer?

Reference no: EM133577930

Questions Cloud

What would make cellphone product business : What would make a cellphone product business , Mobile dog grooming service and pool service stand out from Competition ?

Companies adopt various pricing strategies : Companies adopt various pricing strategies that appeal to their target market. Marketers must also balance the price that generates the required profits

Define internal and external validity : Define internal and external validity and the conditions that impact validity.

How much improvement does the innovation : Describe the product including the date of launch. How much improvement does the innovation provide over previous solutions?

What are some of the challenges in the current peer-review : What are some of the challenges in the current peer-review process, in which the peer reviewer is anonymous but the author is known to the reviewer?

Describe the main line of business of the company : Briefly explain the company and describe the main line of business of the company.

Summarize the news article and the highlighted issues : Could you please summarize the news article and the highlighted issues of the news article. What are your opinion on the issue and the argument

Find current event articles : Find Current Event Articles. The articles can be on any current event, but suggest you try to find articles relating to international business or politics.

How does the board of trustees determine : How does the board of trustees determine the trajectory of a healthcare organization? Does the healthcare triad (governing body, CEO, and medical professionals)

User Account

All Pages