What about validity and soundness

Reference no: EM133231426

Question: What would be the fallacies (straw man, false dilemma, equivocation, slippery slope) be for the following passage?

What about validity and soundness? Premises and conclusion?

Passage:

City council needs to get rid of photo radar right now! It is a mere cash grab set up to inflate their budgets and punish those of us who follow the rules 99% of the time. If they do not remove the photo radar from my street, I will start an online campaign that shows how useless these speed traps are. What is the purpose of city council if not to serve the constituents? I believe my interests are not being served.

Firstly, photo radar doesn't even catch the person while they are speeding, so nothing is being stopped. In other words, if no one was speeding, then we would know with certainty that photo radar works. But people keep speeding. This is because photo radar is merely a passive way of punishing speeders: The only way to truly deter is to catch them in the act.

Secondly, what do they need so much extra money for? We all know that the more they bring in, the more they will spend anyway. So, obviously they will just add more and more photo radar since they depend on the income from photo radar now. Look at all the money they wasted building that soccer facility-I don't even play soccer!

My cousin has been in road construction for 30 years, and he says that photo radar doesn't deter people from speeding anyway. He has seen it time and again on the job. He is building the road and they set up photo radar where no one can see it, so how will they know when to slow down???

I have received three photo radar tickets this month for going only two kilometers over the limit on my street. This is beyond unfair. This is taking money away from my children and their financial security. Does city council want my children to starve?

Would the conclusion be : photo radar is merely a passive way of punishing speeders: The only way to truly deter is to catch them in the act.

Premises: (1) photo radar doesn't even catch the person while they are speeding, so nothing is being stopped

(2) City council needs to get rid of photo radar right now! It is a mere cash grab set up to inflate their budgets and punish those of us who follow the rules 99% of the time.

Reference no: EM133231426

Questions Cloud

Enjoying leisurely lifestyle : If many unemployed are spending around two hours/day looking for work as research indicates, do you think that means they are enjoying "leisurely" lifestyle?

Would it still be moral to slaughter the pig to harvest : PHI 2396 University of Ottawa, shows greater interlligence and even a degree of empathy. would it still be moral to slaughter the pig to harvest its organs

What the benefits with their methods of collaboration : What methods of collaboration between internal and external stakeholders have you observed in your practicum setting. What the benefits with their methods

What do you consider the strongest objections : ETH 321 University of Phoenix, What do you consider the strongest objections to your position and why? What weaknesses and inconsistencies do you see

What about validity and soundness : PHIL 252 Athabasca University, What would be the fallacies (straw man, false dilemma, equivocation, slippery slope) be for the following passage?

Quickly generate list of ideas for speech : Chapter 9 suggests two ways to quickly generate a list of ideas for a speech; they are

How the collaboration methods you selected are effective : What collaboration methods could you use to advocate for a practice improvement strategy? How the collaboration methods you selected are effective

Define the word harm in the context of the harm principle : PHIL-104 Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, Define the word "harm" in the context of "the Harm Principle." Can you have a harm above the line

Discuss on the changing societal priorities : Discuss/reflect on the changing societal priorities and how businesses should respond to these changes.

User Account

All Pages