What about an emergency call into a dispatcher

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133287099

Case: Remember that this is usually only an issue if the "declarant" (victim in this case) is not testifying at trial. The statement in question will then be used (in part) to convict the defendant. This hinges in large part on whether the statement is "testimonial." If it is, it is probably inadmissible absent the ability to cross-examine the witness. Determining if a statement is testimonial depends in part on the "primary purpose" of the interrogation. Were the statements made or elicited with the primary purpose of creating or gathering evidence for prosecuting the defendant? The intent of the declarant is also important in these cases, as pointed out by the Court.

QUESTIONS: 1) Now change the facts from Ohio v Clark. A) What about an emergency call into a dispatcher? B) What about responses to a police officer questioning witnesses at a crime scene? Are these testimonial statements? Why or why not? (Consider each in turn but don't worry about getting the "right" answer. Just consider the readings and support your answers).

2) In your opinion, does it still make sense to adhere to the hearsay rule, or can/should modern juries figure this out on their own, sifting out potentially unreliable statements on a case-by-case basis? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM133287099

Questions Cloud

What is the primary barrier a nurse may face : Nurses Roles in Migrant Vaccination in The US Discussion - What is the primary barrier a nurse may face while working with Jorge's family or similar families

Research criminal or judicial events that have occurred : Research criminal or judicial events that have occurred within the last three months and provided a brief synopsis on what occurred

Difference between calcitonin-parathyroid hormone in body : Explain the difference between Calcitonin and Parathyroid Hormone in the body. Do not copy and paste my own slides, nor simply cut and paste from the internet.

Describe the attack and the decisions needed to be made : CJA 3750 Middle Tennessee State University Describe the attack and the decisions needed to be made regarding whether to intentionally identify the covert

What about an emergency call into a dispatcher : What about an emergency call into a dispatcher? B) What about responses to a police officer questioning witnesses at a crime scene

How does the dnp play a role in quality improvement : How does the DNP play a role in quality improvement? Reflect on the differences between quality improvement and research activities

Identify the steps that the relevant persons : Identify the steps that the relevant persons/entities need to take in order to remove a judge from office for disciplinary reasons for each state

How can corporate culture be changed : How can corporate culture be changed? What are some examples of behavior controls? Output controls? Input controls

Are there any circumstances that you think justify : HSEC 350 Campbell University Are there any circumstances that you think justify these acts by these groups? Do the targets of this type of warfare enter into

User Account

All Pages