Were the actions of the survivors ethical

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133215789

Ethics Case Study

Part I.

A FedEx plane makes an emergency crash landing on a deserted tropical island. Two dozen survivors are forced to fend for themselves until help arrives. None have previous camping, fishing, or hunting experience, and as a result find it difficult to obtain food. One survivor, Axel, goes off by himself, and through considerable time and effort, figures out how to catch fish with the limited resources available. He eventually returns to camp with fish enough to feed everyone. He agrees to share the fish, but he refuses to teach the others how he obtained the fish. Axel makes an offer to the other passengers; he will continue to provide fish, as long as the others do the camp chores for him (fetching fresh water, hauling firewood, etc).

A) Under Kantianism, is Axel's offer ethical? Why or why not?

B) Under Utilitarianism, is Axel's offer ethical? Why or why not?

C) Under Social Contract, is Axel's offer ethical? Why or why not?

Make sure you discuss both elements for each theory.

Part II.

Think back to the Speluncean explorers and discuss the following:

A) Were the actions of the survivors ethical according to Kantianism? Why or why not?

B) Were the actions of the survivors ethical according to Utilitarianism? Why or why not?

C) Were the actions of the survivors ethical according to Social Contract Theory? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM133215789

Questions Cloud

Identify the commercial purpose of a restraint : Identify the commercial purpose of a restraint of trade clause - Advise Daniel whether his proposed restraint of trade clause is enforceable

Encourage current popularity of email : Educators should encourage the current popularity of email and instant messaging among teenagers,

Why should the chief accountant of an organization : Why should the chief accountant of an organization have a clear understanding of both financial and managerial accounting

Creating a compelling team-organization vision : Lead Like Jesus Creating a Compelling Team / Organization Vision. The chapter emphasizes without a clear vision the rest of your leadership skills.

Were the actions of the survivors ethical : Were the actions of the survivors ethical according to Kantianism and Under Kantianism, is Axel's offer ethical? Why or why not?

Did your practicum work experience confirm : What is your overarching career goal? Did your practicum work experience confirm or change your career goal? How?

Do you believe that morals are a part of our law : BUS 21500 Kirtland Community College - Do you believe that morals are a part of our law, or do you believe that morality and law are separate concepts

What are the advantages of managing database information : Your example may be a personal or business database. In addition, what are the advantages of managing database information

Identify the relevant legal remedies : Evaluate the legal differences between the classification of a term of a contract as either a condition or a warranty.

User Account

All Pages