Was this a good decision poorly executed by longstreet

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133355252

Lee's Decision at Gettysburg

We are the midpoint of the course, so it is time to evaluate one of America's greatest battlefield commanders: Robert E. Lee. Many historians place Lee at the pinnacle of command leadership: the risk-taker; revered by his officers and troops; known for his speed of thought and action. His most famous decision, still argued over today, involves his decision to continue the Battle of Gettysburg for a third and final day: ordering Longstreet to assault the center of the Union defenses - the famous "Pickett's Charge." General Longstreet offers a powerful argument against the attack but is overruled by Lee.

After reviewing reading Gompert & Kugler's article and viewing the clip from the movie Gettysburg, critique Lee's decision for Longstreet to assault the Federal lines on the third day. In your initial post, describe the reasons Lee made the decision. Was this a good decision poorly executed by Longstreet? Was this simply a bad decision that had no chance of succeeding? Was it something else?

Reference no: EM133355252

Questions Cloud

Discuss the goals or characteristics of cubism : How does Braque's painting push even further into Cubism/Modernism than Cezanne's? Discuss the goals/characteristics of Cubism.

Root Cause Analysis : Use the logic of Root Cause Analysis and the process of the "5 Whys" described in the chapter to perform a very simple RCA of the failure you experienced

Optimal market organization : what does that suggest for the optimal market organization for used cars. Why? How would your analysis differ for treatment of strokes or cardiac treatment?

Analyze how the middle ages affected europe politically : Analyze how the Middle Ages affected Europe politically, militarily, globally, socially and economically. How did this period shape the modern world?

Was this a good decision poorly executed by longstreet : Was this a good decision poorly executed by Longstreet? Was this simply a bad decision that had no chance of succeeding? Was it something else

What are some possible effects on health as a consequence : adult to minimize the impact of poverty on that adult's health? Let's talk about stress: What are some possible effects on health as a consequence of stress

Identify the three artworks by name and artist : Identify the three artworks by name and artist and supply a link to each work or insert an image of each into your post. How are the images you chose powerful?

Discussions and the chapter material on health care : SYG2000 Southern New Hampshire University At the end of the Health and Health Care chapter, please make any revisions to your plan that you see fit, in light

Why did so many black communities erupt in violence : Why did so many black communities erupt in violence even as the federal government adopted a more active and effectual role in ensuring African Americans

User Account

All Pages