Reference no: EM13960300
CASE: STA TE COURT CASE Discovery
Averyt v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
265 P.3d 456, 2011 Colo. texts 857 (2011) Supreme Court of Colorado
"Rather, any prejudice that the jury may have harbored was due to Wal-Mart's initial refusal to produce evidence of or admit the evidence of the grease spill." -Rice, Justice
Facts
Holly Averyt, a commercial truck driver, slipped in grease while making a delivery to Wal-Mart store number 980 in Greeley, Colorado. As a result of the fall, Averyt ruptured a disc in her spine and injured her shoulder and neck. These injuries left her unable to perform many daily functions. Averyt sued Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (Wal-Mart), alleging claims of negligence and premises liability.
Averyt's attorney sought evidence from Wal-Mart documenting the grease spill, but Wal-Mart denied the existence of the grease spill and did not turn over documents to Averyt. During opening statements on the first day of trial, Wal-Mart denied the existence of the grease spill. On that day, Averyt's attorney contacted the government of the City of Greeley and discovered a memorandum that referenced the grease spill and documentation of the cleanup of the spill. Averyt impeached a Wal-Mart witness' statements using the Greeley report.
The next morning, Wal-Mart informed the court and Averyt that it had located an assistant manager who remembered the grease spill and disclosed numerous documents that confirmed the existence of the spill, including documents from three companies that were involved in cleaning up the spill. From that point forward, Wal-Mart ceased to deny the existence of the grease spill and instead asserted that it had exercised reasonable care to clean up the spill.
The jury found in Averyt's favor and awarded her $15 million in damages. The trial court judge applied a legal cap on damages, reducing the award to approximately $11 million. Wal-Mart made a motion for a new trial, alleging nondisclosure of the Greeley re-port by plaintiffs before being introduced at trial and unfair prejudice of the jury. The trial court granted Wal-Mart's motion for a new trial. Averyt appealed.
Issue
Was the jury unduly prejudiced against Wal-Mart?
Language of the Court
Discovery is not required of public documents. In short, the report is a publicly available record that Averyt's attorney obtained from the City of Greeley. Averyt and Wal-Mart were on equal footing with regard to the ability to obtain the report. Any prejudice that the jury may have harbored was due to Wal-Mart's initial refusal to produce evidence of or admit the evidence of the grease spill. We do not find that the jury's award was the result of unfair prejudice. There is also adequate support in the record to justify the jury's award.
Decision
The supreme court of Colorado reversed the trial court's order granting a new trial, thus upholding the $11 million award to plaintiff Averyt.
Ethics Questions
Do you think that Wal-Mart willfully did not disclose the evidence of the grease spill? Did the jury consider Wal-Mart's conduct when it reached its verdict?
|
How much safety inventory of cell phones
: Weekly demand for Motorola cell phones at a Best Buy store is normally distributed with a mean of 300 and a standard deviation of 200. Motorola takes two weeks to supply a Best Buy order. Best Buy is targeting a cycle service level of 95 percent and ..
|
|
Find speed of bead at bottom and reaction of wire on bead
: A bead slides on a smooth rigid wire bent into the form of a circular loop of radius b. If the plane of the loop is vertical and if the bead starts from rest at a point that is level with the center of the loop, find the speed of the bead at the ..
|
|
Risk-return and the capital asset pricing model
: This week we focus our attention to Risk, Return, and the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). One of the primary concepts in the field of finance is the risk-reward trade off. An assumption of risk-reward is the tenet of risk aversion for investor..
|
|
How many boxes should the inventory analyst order
: Assume that weekly demand for boxes of Legos at Wal-Mart is normally distributed with a mean of 2,500 boxes and a standard deviation of 500 boxes. The replenishment lead time is two weeks and the inventory is reviewed and an order is placed every 4 w..
|
|
Was the jury unduly prejudiced against wal-mart
: Do you think that Wal-Mart willfully did not disclose the evidence of the grease spill? Did the jury consider Wal-Mart's conduct when it reached its verdict? Was the jury unduly prejudiced against Wal-Mart?
|
|
What might have been one or two ethical issues
: You may recall hearing about a past legal case in which a woman sued McDonalds because of burns she received when hot coffee spilled in her lap. At the time, she was riding in her nephew’s sports car and they purchased the coffee at McDonalds’ drive-..
|
|
Plot the level load curve and determine the engine power
: Determine the overall gear ratios for 4th and 5th gears - Choose an appropriate engine speed at which peak torque will be developed; convert the chosen mean effective pressure values at peak power and peak torque into torque values at the flywheel.
|
|
What is the probability that the ball may be brown is
: Box A contains three balls with colors red, green and blue and box B contains a balls with colors red, yellow ,blue, white and brown A box is chosen and a ball is picked. What is the probability that the ball may be brown is? What is the probability ..
|
|
Limited-life intangible assets
: As of 12-31-13, G owned several limited-life intangible assets. During 2014, G purchased an unlimited-life intangible asset for $60,000.
|