Was the alabama supreme court correct

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131377350

Steven Gwin bought a lifetime Termite Protection Plan for his home in Alabama from the local office of Allied-Bruce, a franchise of Terminix International Company. The plan provided that Allied-Bruce would ‘‘protect'' Gwin's house against termite infestation, reinspect periodically, provide additional treatment if necessary, and repair damage caused by new termite infestations. Terminix International guaranteed the fulfillment of these contractual provisions.

The plan also provided that all disputes arising out of the contract would be settled exclusively by arbitration. Four years later, Gwin had Allied-Bruce reinspect the house in anticipation of selling it. Allied-Bruce gave the house a ‘‘clean bill of health.'' Gwin then sold the house and transferred the Termite Protection Plan to Dobson.

Shortly thereafter, Dobson found the house to be infested with termites. Allied-Bruce attempted to treat and repair the house, using materials from out of state, but these efforts failed to satisfy Dobson. Dobson then sued Gwin, Allied-Bruce, and Terminix International in an Alabama state court. Allied-Bruce and Terminix International asked for a stay of these proceedings until arbitration could be carried out as stipulated in the contract. The trial court refused to grant the stay. The Alabama Supreme Court upheld that ruling, citing a state statute that makes predispute arbitration agreements unenforceable.

The court found that the Federal Arbitration Act, which preempts conflicting state law, did not apply to this contract because its connection to interstate commerce was too slight. Was the Alabama Supreme Court correct? Explain.

Reference no: EM131377350

Questions Cloud

Does the federal court have jurisdiction : Mariana Deutsch worked as a knitwear mender and attended a school for beauticians.- The district court dismissed the suit, and Deutsch appealed. Does the federal court have jurisdiction? Explain.
Determine the minimum cross sectional area : Determine the minimum cross sectional area the cable shown must have if the allowable stress in the cable is 10,000 psi. Check both lengths AC and CD and let the most critical portion control the size for the whole length ACD.
Should the petition of perry and johnson be granted : Perry and Johnston filed a petition in a California state court to compel arbitration under Section 2 of the Federal Arbitration Act, which was enacted pursuant to the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Should the petition of Perry and John..
Determine the pressures at all the four points of contact : If the bottom width of of the box where the two cylinders are fitted is 180 mm, with one side vertical and the other inclined at 60°, determine the pressures at all the four points of contact.
Was the alabama supreme court correct : The court found that the Federal Arbitration Act, which preempts conflicting state law, did not apply to this contract because its connection to interstate commerce was too slight. Was the Alabama Supreme Court correct? Explain.
Identify and analyze the possible impacts : Identify and analyze the possible impacts (political, environmental, health, safety, cultural, economic) of the electric car technology on society (including individual, local, regional, or global context)
The free-rider problem arises because : Recall the Application 1 in the textbook. Clearing Space Debris. Fill in the blanks: The clearing of space debris is an example of a _____ that suffers from the _____ problem. The free-rider problem arises because. During pledge week your local publi..
Arguing that she was denied due process : Allen brings an action against the city and Baldwin for damages for loss of the vehicle, arguing that she was denied due process. Decision?
What role would information technology play in your proposal : How do information technologies contribute to the business success of Sew What? Inc.? Give several examples from the case regarding the business value of information technology that demonstrate this conclusion.

Reviews

Write a Review

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  Learning in action

Learning contract proposal that will form the basis of your learning contract report.

  Change is the only constant

"Change is the only constant " Evaluate the different types of change that have occurred in Sony.

  How do advertisers try to use group influence

How do advertisers try to use group influence?  Will you find any specific examples and explain the relevant theory of group behavior and influence?

  Case study:saving sony

You have been appointed by Sony as a consultant on change management. Advise Sony on how they could implement the change by using the various theories of change you have learnt.

  How the stock market works

The purpose of this project is to help you to gain an understanding of how the stock market works and of the relationship between theory and practice.

  Find the optimal production quantities

Find not only the optimal production quantities, but also the optimal total cost.

  Describe the management process

Describe the management process and identify the skills required to manage business organizations.

  Case study : bert''s bonsai and aquatic sport museum

Case Study : Bert's Bonsai and Aquatic Sport Museum Prepare a knowledge management system.

  Knowledge management techniques

Demonstrate understanding of the many-sided nature of knowledge management

  Theory of transtheoretical model

Demonstrate understanding of the many-sided nature of knowledge management

  Write a paper on historical trends of management

Write a paper on Historical Trends of Management.

  Theory of reasoned action

Theory of Planned Behavior and Integrated Behaviors Model

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd